It's interesting that there's quite little "consensus media", i.e. stuff that everyone knows about and is interested in.
The era when one episode of a TV show comes out every week and it's the talk of the town/office is dead. Nothing has the draw of a new Star Wars/LOTR movie coming out anymore since the internet means everyone consumes whatever caters to their exact interests.
A few pieces of consensus culture survive, James Bond being one of them. I wonder what's leading to its durability.
I like Pattinson, but the fact that they didn't cast a rather unknown actor (as they did in the past) signals that they don't think their script and the James Bond brand could be sufficient to attract audiences on its own.
That's either because they are not confident in what they have or aim for 1bn USD in revenue, both is not really a comforting perspective...
I just saw Noah Wiley on the cover of some magazine as the "sexiest man alive"... I think he already won this award, some 25 years ago.
I think there is a general dearth of new famous young actors. Primetime TV used to be built on no name actors getting huge, on Disney/Nickelodeon kid stars transitioning into adulthood. Now we just have high budget Netflix/Apple series and social media stars.
I can feel the actor pipeline calcifying, through some combination of young actors not having a path to "get good" and a general trend of old actors extending their peak through various means.
And let's not discount the beancounters' focus on Known Commodities, which is why we have so many sequels. Movies have been co-opted by big money, like everything else.
I think they're aiming for a super high box office and are confident. Denis V is basically a money printer as a director right now, I know a ton of people who were excited about the movie just because he was directing. This is a safe choice that will not mess up the hype.
Fan of the franchise, have even read some of the original novels.
He strikes me as being a bit too young/pretty for the role. Bond is a bit of a grizzled veteran, older and a bit weary, but also a credible threat. Daniel Craig was absolutely ideal: He had the look, and played it fantastically. This makes me worry about a return to the worst Bond: Roger Moore, where they really played up Bond as a non-serious playboy.
He might be great though. I'll be there for the next movie, whenever it is.
Craig was basically unknown, Brosnan was a recognizable face, but hardly on the level of Pattinson. Apparently there were bonds before that, but I wouldn’t know anything about that.
Good news for the Bond, but I'm a little disappointed to see Pattinson locked in to these movies for the next few years. I have no doubt he'll elevate the material, but an actor with such an amazing range playing the same character over and over feels like a bit of a waste.
> I never got the feeling Bond was supposed to be in his 40s.
Funny, as a child/teenager, watching bond movies, I never got the feeling that he's supposed to be any younger than 40. Brosnan/Connery/Craig all looked at least 40 in their first movie.
The persona/demeanor of Bond was always "been around the block for a while, had some romances here and there, been an alcoholic and recovered once or twice" and becoming 007 is sort of a redemption arc to be able to go out in a blaze of glory and relive the rambunctious youth days.
If anything he is too young looking. According to wikipedia Bond is supposed to be between mid and late thirties. And when looking at the pictures of Bond according to Fleming, it wan's t 2026's thirties
I wonder if James Bond's shouldn't simply be put out to pasture. I mean, he's a symbol of the 1960's era complete with miniskirts and sexism. You can modernize him with a monogamist lifestyle and such, but then he wouldn't be Bond anymore.
I think they've done a pretty good job modernizing him over the years while retaining the core that makes him fun; the Brosnan films characterized him as a relic of a bygone age, and his sexism and whatnot that played as cool in the original films translated into sort of 'lovable scamp' in line with cultural norms at the time.
Then the Craig films went in a more psychological direction, painting him as deeply flawed character who is unwilling to form deep attachments or show vulnerability as a defense mechanism born of trauma -- plus, they began pairing him with stronger female leads who were able to challenge him, rather than just play the damsel in distress, which worked great, both for him as a character and the movies in general.
I don't know how they might reinterpret the character to bring him in line with modern day cultural expectations, but that's one thing they've been pretty good about historically.
It's interesting that there's quite little "consensus media", i.e. stuff that everyone knows about and is interested in.
The era when one episode of a TV show comes out every week and it's the talk of the town/office is dead. Nothing has the draw of a new Star Wars/LOTR movie coming out anymore since the internet means everyone consumes whatever caters to their exact interests.
A few pieces of consensus culture survive, James Bond being one of them. I wonder what's leading to its durability.
> Nothing has the draw of a new Star Wars/LOTR movie coming out anymore
It seemed like Project Hail Mary managed to capture something close to this level of attention.
GTA VI?
I guess you missed Dune?
I like Pattinson, but the fact that they didn't cast a rather unknown actor (as they did in the past) signals that they don't think their script and the James Bond brand could be sufficient to attract audiences on its own.
That's either because they are not confident in what they have or aim for 1bn USD in revenue, both is not really a comforting perspective...
I just saw Noah Wiley on the cover of some magazine as the "sexiest man alive"... I think he already won this award, some 25 years ago.
I think there is a general dearth of new famous young actors. Primetime TV used to be built on no name actors getting huge, on Disney/Nickelodeon kid stars transitioning into adulthood. Now we just have high budget Netflix/Apple series and social media stars.
I can feel the actor pipeline calcifying, through some combination of young actors not having a path to "get good" and a general trend of old actors extending their peak through various means.
And let's not discount the beancounters' focus on Known Commodities, which is why we have so many sequels. Movies have been co-opted by big money, like everything else.
I think they're aiming for a super high box office and are confident. Denis V is basically a money printer as a director right now, I know a ton of people who were excited about the movie just because he was directing. This is a safe choice that will not mess up the hype.
Pattinson certainly can portrait a believable Bond. I don't see a problem there. People had much more doubts when Daniel Craig was announced as Bond.
But the more interesting bit is that Villeneuve will direct the movie and Steven Knight will be writing the script.
That's gonna be interesting.
Fan of the franchise, have even read some of the original novels.
He strikes me as being a bit too young/pretty for the role. Bond is a bit of a grizzled veteran, older and a bit weary, but also a credible threat. Daniel Craig was absolutely ideal: He had the look, and played it fantastically. This makes me worry about a return to the worst Bond: Roger Moore, where they really played up Bond as a non-serious playboy.
He might be great though. I'll be there for the next movie, whenever it is.
Gotta admit, I'm happier seeing Villeneuve direct it than Pattinson play it. It could work.
Damn. I like pattinson, but not for bond. Give me a relative unknown like craig was, not one of the biggest stars of our time.
Heard this about most actors chosen for this role, tbh
Craig was basically unknown, Brosnan was a recognizable face, but hardly on the level of Pattinson. Apparently there were bonds before that, but I wouldn’t know anything about that.
What about Sean Connery?
Bond is what made him.
Timothy Dalton had an established career when he was tapped (for the second time, see below). Too bad the movies he got saddled with were mostly crap.
Dalton was originally tapped, I think, before Connery. He was 007 fan. He declined, because he felt Bond should be played by an older actor.
Good news for the Bond, but I'm a little disappointed to see Pattinson locked in to these movies for the next few years. I have no doubt he'll elevate the material, but an actor with such an amazing range playing the same character over and over feels like a bit of a waste.
dupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50518615
Amazon/MGM post: https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/entertainment/james-bond-ro...
Another old Bond. I never got the feeling Bond was supposed to be in his 40s.
> I never got the feeling Bond was supposed to be in his 40s.
Funny, as a child/teenager, watching bond movies, I never got the feeling that he's supposed to be any younger than 40. Brosnan/Connery/Craig all looked at least 40 in their first movie.
The persona/demeanor of Bond was always "been around the block for a while, had some romances here and there, been an alcoholic and recovered once or twice" and becoming 007 is sort of a redemption arc to be able to go out in a blaze of glory and relive the rambunctious youth days.
That experience is hard to fit under 30.
Isn't he canonically mid-thirties to mid-forties in the books? Robert Pattinson is 40 which is a little old to be starting, but eh, not too far off.
If anything he is too young looking. According to wikipedia Bond is supposed to be between mid and late thirties. And when looking at the pictures of Bond according to Fleming, it wan's t 2026's thirties
I wonder if James Bond's shouldn't simply be put out to pasture. I mean, he's a symbol of the 1960's era complete with miniskirts and sexism. You can modernize him with a monogamist lifestyle and such, but then he wouldn't be Bond anymore.
I think they've done a pretty good job modernizing him over the years while retaining the core that makes him fun; the Brosnan films characterized him as a relic of a bygone age, and his sexism and whatnot that played as cool in the original films translated into sort of 'lovable scamp' in line with cultural norms at the time.
Then the Craig films went in a more psychological direction, painting him as deeply flawed character who is unwilling to form deep attachments or show vulnerability as a defense mechanism born of trauma -- plus, they began pairing him with stronger female leads who were able to challenge him, rather than just play the damsel in distress, which worked great, both for him as a character and the movies in general.
I don't know how they might reinterpret the character to bring him in line with modern day cultural expectations, but that's one thing they've been pretty good about historically.
Modernize by making him monogamous?! A modern Bond would be solo-poly, meeting sources on feeld
Policing women's bodies and clothing, on the other hand...
But Henry Cavill is too old ;)
should not be on HN
Can you make the whole movie with an AI? You give the scenario and it will produce the whole movie. No need to pay for actors and cameraman etc.