UPDATE: It appears that I was wrong and that this is a feature of screen time and not of Duolingo. Any app that is granted screen time permissions requires screen time password to delete (or requires you to revoke the screen time permissions).
I'm not locked out, I just intentionally don't know my screen time password (my SO does). I just posted because I thought duolingo was explicitly using the screen time password to block uninstall, but I was wrong.
I'm not a huge fan of Duolingo from a language learning perspective, but it is slightly educational Vs. generic addictive games.
That being said - This isn't a dark pattern. This is two things interacting in a way that makes sense if you stop and consider them for a second.
Duolingo, when used like this, uses Apple's Family Controls framework (Screen Time API), registering itself via AuthorizationCenter.shared.requestAuthorization(for: .individual) as a Screen Time-authorized app, just like any fully featured parental control app.
When you attempt to remove a parental control app, rightfully, iOS wants to verify you have the Screen Time pin/are a "parent" to prevent a child from removing it (and bypassing restrictions).
Is it actually Duolingo that blocks it, or is it iOS due to the fact that Duolingo has set some screen time permissions? To me it looks pretty useless with screen time permissions if anyone just can remove the app and thus disable what ever rules the app had set.
Yep, you're right, I was a bit over eager posting this. I made a bare SwiftUI app that does nothing but request screen time permissions, and it blocked uninstall once it was granted.
> If you don't know your screen time password (which I don't), this effectively stops you from ever deleting the Duolingo app, even if you disable the "block other apps" feature later on.
Why don't you know your screen time password? This is a parental control feature.
My SO knows my screen time password, the idea (for me) is that there's some extra friction when I want to bypass. I think this is a pretty common pattern.
That sounds like a good way to reducing conflict too. Keep the SO happy, or lose control of your device for... however long it takes to make up. But there's also the flip side that you're potentially stuck in a rut if anything happens to them...
This seems like an iOS problem? Apps from the store shouldn't be able to make themselves uninstallable, and even if they can block uinstallation it while acting as a "blocker for 'time wasting apps'", they should be uninstallable again once they've lost that permission.
Duolingo might be being malicious here, but it seems like a bug in iOS to me.
Blocking uninstallation is frankly fine. What matters is an investigation into just how much information Duolingo and other custom screen time apps can glean. The API should only allow apps to set and remove restrictions, but not see which apps are actually being used. In fact I wouldn’t even want Duolingo to enumerate the list of installed apps: it should be an API where iOS itself asks me which apps should be restricted by Duolingo, and Duolingo merely sets this Boolean.
I find that neither Duolingo nor Apple adequately explained the privacy of this feature. Duolingo has asked me a couple of times if I want to enable this feature and I am simply uncomfortable enabling it. I think this deserves more investigation than the block-uninstall issue.
> it's worth noting that the first option here is literally "All Apps and Categories"
Go to your iPhone screen time settings and try to add a limit for a app. The first option will be "All Apps and Categories". This interface is entired built by apple.
> If you don't know your screen time password (which I don't), this effectively stops you from ever deleting the Duolingo app
I mean, is this how screen time on iPhone suppose to work.
And I think putting the update at the bottom of your blog is also worth noting.
Entirely useless is a bit harsh. If you just do the bare minimum aka spending two minutes per day to do one lesson to keep the streak alive, yeah your progress is negligible. When I did this I pretty much only gained vocabulary.
But if you are a serious language learner you’d spend at least thirty minutes per day in the app doing not just the main lessons but also the practices and reviews. Many of the lessons like listening lessons don’t require you to understand every word before you know the answers to the quizzes but you can aim higher and challenge yourself to understand every word. In that case Duolingo isn’t too bad.
Not in my experience - if you're consistent at practicing each day you can become decently fluent. Is it the most efficient method? Obviously not. But I know zero Spanish speaking people in my daily life, and it's a lot more fun to me than reading textbooks or studying flashcards.
i have no idea about consensus, but i found it to be largely useless when i tried to learn spanish. All sorts of completely irrelevant vocab, and all you really learn is how to be good at playing the game of Duolingo.
Most people I talk to about this (who use duolingo) don't seem to care. I think the venn diagram of people _actually_ trying to learn a language, versus not-really-caring-but-just-having-a-bit-of fun doesn't overlap very much
Yeah I'm basically hooked because I don't want to "lose my - 6-year - streak" (actually lost months ago but they have it designed so it can be "restored"), and I also feel somehow obligated to keep going for friends I'm connected to there. Have to admit they have the psychology down pretty well.
UPDATE: It appears that I was wrong and that this is a feature of screen time and not of Duolingo. Any app that is granted screen time permissions requires screen time password to delete (or requires you to revoke the screen time permissions).
How to reset your screen time password: https://support.apple.com/en-us/102677
I'm not locked out, I just intentionally don't know my screen time password (my SO does). I just posted because I thought duolingo was explicitly using the screen time password to block uninstall, but I was wrong.
I'm not a huge fan of Duolingo from a language learning perspective, but it is slightly educational Vs. generic addictive games.
That being said - This isn't a dark pattern. This is two things interacting in a way that makes sense if you stop and consider them for a second.
Duolingo, when used like this, uses Apple's Family Controls framework (Screen Time API), registering itself via AuthorizationCenter.shared.requestAuthorization(for: .individual) as a Screen Time-authorized app, just like any fully featured parental control app.
When you attempt to remove a parental control app, rightfully, iOS wants to verify you have the Screen Time pin/are a "parent" to prevent a child from removing it (and bypassing restrictions).
Yeah you're right, I posted update in a different comment. The post got flagged too for the same mistake (I think).
I'm happy to delete post too, I'm just not a frequent HN poster so not sure what the standard is.
Is it actually Duolingo that blocks it, or is it iOS due to the fact that Duolingo has set some screen time permissions? To me it looks pretty useless with screen time permissions if anyone just can remove the app and thus disable what ever rules the app had set.
Yep, you're right, I was a bit over eager posting this. I made a bare SwiftUI app that does nothing but request screen time permissions, and it blocked uninstall once it was granted.
> If you don't know your screen time password (which I don't), this effectively stops you from ever deleting the Duolingo app, even if you disable the "block other apps" feature later on.
Why don't you know your screen time password? This is a parental control feature.
Easily reset as well: https://support.apple.com/en-us/102677
My SO knows my screen time password, the idea (for me) is that there's some extra friction when I want to bypass. I think this is a pretty common pattern.
That sounds like a good way to reducing conflict too. Keep the SO happy, or lose control of your device for... however long it takes to make up. But there's also the flip side that you're potentially stuck in a rut if anything happens to them...
Well then, it doesn't "effectively stops you from ever deleting the Duolingo app".
This seems like an iOS problem? Apps from the store shouldn't be able to make themselves uninstallable, and even if they can block uinstallation it while acting as a "blocker for 'time wasting apps'", they should be uninstallable again once they've lost that permission.
Duolingo might be being malicious here, but it seems like a bug in iOS to me.
Yep I posted update in thread. I was wrong, it's a screen time feature not on duolingo.
I think this is very overstated and a feature of screen time itself blocking the uninstall, so maybe not truly a dark pattern.
Blocking uninstallation is frankly fine. What matters is an investigation into just how much information Duolingo and other custom screen time apps can glean. The API should only allow apps to set and remove restrictions, but not see which apps are actually being used. In fact I wouldn’t even want Duolingo to enumerate the list of installed apps: it should be an API where iOS itself asks me which apps should be restricted by Duolingo, and Duolingo merely sets this Boolean.
I find that neither Duolingo nor Apple adequately explained the privacy of this feature. Duolingo has asked me a couple of times if I want to enable this feature and I am simply uncomfortable enabling it. I think this deserves more investigation than the block-uninstall issue.
This is completly not on Duolingo at all.
> it's worth noting that the first option here is literally "All Apps and Categories"
Go to your iPhone screen time settings and try to add a limit for a app. The first option will be "All Apps and Categories". This interface is entired built by apple.
> If you don't know your screen time password (which I don't), this effectively stops you from ever deleting the Duolingo app
I mean, is this how screen time on iPhone suppose to work.
And I think putting the update at the bottom of your blog is also worth noting.
I added the update to the blog
I found duolingo entirely useless as a language learning app. It is just an addictive memory and pattern recognition game.
Entirely useless is a bit harsh. If you just do the bare minimum aka spending two minutes per day to do one lesson to keep the streak alive, yeah your progress is negligible. When I did this I pretty much only gained vocabulary.
But if you are a serious language learner you’d spend at least thirty minutes per day in the app doing not just the main lessons but also the practices and reviews. Many of the lessons like listening lessons don’t require you to understand every word before you know the answers to the quizzes but you can aim higher and challenge yourself to understand every word. In that case Duolingo isn’t too bad.
Isn’t the consensus now that Duolingo is pretty useless if you actually want to learn the language. But good if you want to learn a couple of phrases
Not in my experience - if you're consistent at practicing each day you can become decently fluent. Is it the most efficient method? Obviously not. But I know zero Spanish speaking people in my daily life, and it's a lot more fun to me than reading textbooks or studying flashcards.
i have no idea about consensus, but i found it to be largely useless when i tried to learn spanish. All sorts of completely irrelevant vocab, and all you really learn is how to be good at playing the game of Duolingo.
This is the best resource im aware of for learning languages https://www.languagetransfer.org
Most people I talk to about this (who use duolingo) don't seem to care. I think the venn diagram of people _actually_ trying to learn a language, versus not-really-caring-but-just-having-a-bit-of fun doesn't overlap very much
Based on what?
Duolingo is optimized to keep users coming back to the app every day. They've been the butt of jokes among language influencers for a while now.
In my experience it was not bad for learning some basics about a language, but you quickly the point of diminishing returns (2-4 weeks).
I haven't used it since they switched over to a fully generative "AI Slop" approach to creating their content, though.
Yeah I'm basically hooked because I don't want to "lose my - 6-year - streak" (actually lost months ago but they have it designed so it can be "restored"), and I also feel somehow obligated to keep going for friends I'm connected to there. Have to admit they have the psychology down pretty well.
It's a competitive online game disguised as a language learning app.