Releasing AI to the general public so quickly was a mistake. On top of the employment issues, we have growing cyberattacks daily and defenders can't keep up.
Someone will still need to grow my food and they will not employ machines because of cheap "human labour" so humans would always find employment and also so much negative publicity about machines that atleast if not all then many will hate machines too much to employ them. And how would I pay for my food you say? Oh I will polish some stone some gem, or write some poem for the entertainment of the farmer supposingly that I would be landless and the farmers would be the ones owning land. I could make embroidery leather shoes or i could shine the leather shoes with a mirror shine. These things I can do. Basically village and cottage occupations would still survive even if AI frenzy doesn't go bust on its face.
And I could always join a future militia which smashes the machine to pieces thus outlawing them in our area of influence. So these researchers can cry doom all they want, it's not gonna happen
> So these researchers can cry doom all they want, it's not gonna happen
Transcript, search "doom". No results found.
Unemployment isn't itself doom. UBI requires enough automation to provide all our needs if none of us did any work, and UBI is just a pension age of "at birth".
Doom neither requires, nor does it follow automatically from, full automation: the risk happens sooner than that, and the best possible outcome also makes work optional for all.
Doom comes from the possibility of automation being tasked with something incompatible with life. Perhaps deliberately, perhaps through the incompetence of the operator or operators, perhaps through the incompetence of the people who created the automation.
There are many forms such doom could take; if it were few, we could simply tackle them head-on to avoid them.
> Someone will still need to grow my food and they will not employ machines because of cheap "human labour" so humans would always find employment and also so much negative publicity about machines that atleast if not all then many will hate machines too much to employ them.
Agriculture was the first major sector to be automated; and if it wasn't for all the mechanisation already in agriculture, 90% of us would have to work in that sector just to make the food we eat. "Battery farming" of eggs is basically a machine that happens to house live chickens.
India is largest producer of milk. Never seen autonomous milking machines. Rather I notice a trend in India that transitioning from 4 or 8 cows to 100 cows is nearly impoverishing the farmers. Because somehow the finances don't work or the business fails. So I don't think that these autonomous things will be as capable absolutely everywhere as you or the researchers seem to think.
Source: I have worked in agri business department of a bank in India in my previous job so I'm reading up dairy news and videos of India
Moderately surprising. I know the country only reached 100% household electrification this decade (no shade, my ancestors were not the benevolent ones they like to tell themselves they were), but I'd expect you to have at least seen one of these machines given how long they've been around for.
Norway is not the whole world. Autonomous will not work everywhere.
Autonomous works in Norway because human labour is not cheap there as everyone is rich because of crude oil subsidising everything there. Not every country is exporting crude oil to finance dairy automation
Automation can be expensive to buy, but it is what makes the end result cheap. And by the same process, automation in the factory that makes the automation, makes the automation cheaper, or better for the same price; this has already happened with such equipment.
Releasing AI to the general public so quickly was a mistake. On top of the employment issues, we have growing cyberattacks daily and defenders can't keep up.
Someone will still need to grow my food and they will not employ machines because of cheap "human labour" so humans would always find employment and also so much negative publicity about machines that atleast if not all then many will hate machines too much to employ them. And how would I pay for my food you say? Oh I will polish some stone some gem, or write some poem for the entertainment of the farmer supposingly that I would be landless and the farmers would be the ones owning land. I could make embroidery leather shoes or i could shine the leather shoes with a mirror shine. These things I can do. Basically village and cottage occupations would still survive even if AI frenzy doesn't go bust on its face. And I could always join a future militia which smashes the machine to pieces thus outlawing them in our area of influence. So these researchers can cry doom all they want, it's not gonna happen
> So these researchers can cry doom all they want, it's not gonna happen
Transcript, search "doom". No results found.
Unemployment isn't itself doom. UBI requires enough automation to provide all our needs if none of us did any work, and UBI is just a pension age of "at birth".
Doom neither requires, nor does it follow automatically from, full automation: the risk happens sooner than that, and the best possible outcome also makes work optional for all.
Doom comes from the possibility of automation being tasked with something incompatible with life. Perhaps deliberately, perhaps through the incompetence of the operator or operators, perhaps through the incompetence of the people who created the automation.
There are many forms such doom could take; if it were few, we could simply tackle them head-on to avoid them.
> Someone will still need to grow my food and they will not employ machines because of cheap "human labour" so humans would always find employment and also so much negative publicity about machines that atleast if not all then many will hate machines too much to employ them.
Agriculture was the first major sector to be automated; and if it wasn't for all the mechanisation already in agriculture, 90% of us would have to work in that sector just to make the food we eat. "Battery farming" of eggs is basically a machine that happens to house live chickens.
But now?
We've had cow milking robots since the 90s: https://www.lely.com/solutions/milking/astronaut/
Here's a weeding robot: https://farmdroid.com/products/farmdroid-fd20/
An autonomous tractor: https://www.agxeed.com/
A whole bunch of agricultural robotics: https://www.agrobot.com
India is largest producer of milk. Never seen autonomous milking machines. Rather I notice a trend in India that transitioning from 4 or 8 cows to 100 cows is nearly impoverishing the farmers. Because somehow the finances don't work or the business fails. So I don't think that these autonomous things will be as capable absolutely everywhere as you or the researchers seem to think. Source: I have worked in agri business department of a bank in India in my previous job so I'm reading up dairy news and videos of India
> India is largest producer of milk.
Unsurprising. It's big.
> Never seen autonomous milking machines.
Moderately surprising. I know the country only reached 100% household electrification this decade (no shade, my ancestors were not the benevolent ones they like to tell themselves they were), but I'd expect you to have at least seen one of these machines given how long they've been around for.
In Norway, 47% of the milk came from an automated milking machine by 2018, and was still rising: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1016/j.njas.2019.100...
Norway is not the whole world. Autonomous will not work everywhere. Autonomous works in Norway because human labour is not cheap there as everyone is rich because of crude oil subsidising everything there. Not every country is exporting crude oil to finance dairy automation
Once upon a time, not everywhere could afford electricity, either.
Automation in agriculture is why fewer Indians work today in the primary sector than they did 25 years ago, even as the population has risen: https://rbi.org.in/scriptS/PublicationsView.aspx?id=23979
Automation can be expensive to buy, but it is what makes the end result cheap. And by the same process, automation in the factory that makes the automation, makes the automation cheaper, or better for the same price; this has already happened with such equipment.