Automated driving systems do great at handling the easy 99% of the cases they encounter on the road. This is not what we should measure them by.
What we should measure automated driving systems on is how they handle the edge cases. And only the edge cases.
The easy 99% is just table stakes that everyone should be assumed to be able to handle, and they should be tossed in jail for crimes against humanity if they can’t.
For the edge cases:
Good behavior that should be encouraged is where any reasonable person would look at that incident and say “How the heck did you survive that?”
Bad behavior that should be discouraged is where any reasonable person would look at that incident and say “Who the hell was the idiot behind the wheel on that disaster?”
Between those extremes, I would say that we should strongly punish bad behavior much more than we reward good behavior.
We need to make it hurt. Not just hurt their bottom line, but hold the executives of that company personally liable and accountable for all civil and criminal legal action that may result from bad behavior on edge cases. Unlimited liability on their part. No indemnification possible. They should have to prove themselves and their systems to be 100% innocent, if they want to avoid liability.
I was sitting in a parking lot waiting for my wife. In the short time I was
there I saw two things and got a phone call about another.
1) a woman tried to pull into a parking space next to the shopping cart
return. She hit it with her front bumper and continued to push the whole
structure until she slipped past it. The cart return had other cars parked
nearby. Had she pushed it further she would have damaged three other cars.
2) a man pulled in next to me. He was looking through the steering wheel
rather than over it. He was VERY close to my car. When he got out he had
a severe stoop due to a bent back. I'm pretty sure he has trouble judging
the outline of his car.
3) a woman I know personally drove through a red light and got t-boned.
Her son arrived before the police. He found her uninjured but completely
unaware of what happened and was very confused.
Teslas don't do this.
I have "driven" my Tesla on FSD since September 2025. Ninety-six percent
of all driving in those 13 months was FSD, including a trip from Pittsburgh
to Lousianna then to Jacksonville then home. If I never "drive" again I will
be perfectly happy.
Automated driving systems do great at handling the easy 99% of the cases they encounter on the road. This is not what we should measure them by.
What we should measure automated driving systems on is how they handle the edge cases. And only the edge cases.
The easy 99% is just table stakes that everyone should be assumed to be able to handle, and they should be tossed in jail for crimes against humanity if they can’t.
For the edge cases:
Good behavior that should be encouraged is where any reasonable person would look at that incident and say “How the heck did you survive that?”
Bad behavior that should be discouraged is where any reasonable person would look at that incident and say “Who the hell was the idiot behind the wheel on that disaster?”
Between those extremes, I would say that we should strongly punish bad behavior much more than we reward good behavior.
We need to make it hurt. Not just hurt their bottom line, but hold the executives of that company personally liable and accountable for all civil and criminal legal action that may result from bad behavior on edge cases. Unlimited liability on their part. No indemnification possible. They should have to prove themselves and their systems to be 100% innocent, if they want to avoid liability.
I was sitting in a parking lot waiting for my wife. In the short time I was there I saw two things and got a phone call about another.
1) a woman tried to pull into a parking space next to the shopping cart return. She hit it with her front bumper and continued to push the whole structure until she slipped past it. The cart return had other cars parked nearby. Had she pushed it further she would have damaged three other cars.
2) a man pulled in next to me. He was looking through the steering wheel rather than over it. He was VERY close to my car. When he got out he had a severe stoop due to a bent back. I'm pretty sure he has trouble judging the outline of his car.
3) a woman I know personally drove through a red light and got t-boned. Her son arrived before the police. He found her uninjured but completely unaware of what happened and was very confused.
Teslas don't do this.
I have "driven" my Tesla on FSD since September 2025. Ninety-six percent of all driving in those 13 months was FSD, including a trip from Pittsburgh to Lousianna then to Jacksonville then home. If I never "drive" again I will be perfectly happy.
Both problems are solved by a Tesla.