Many times a simpler system can be made by relaxing unnecessary [0] requirements, and I think this is one of those cases.
Many sites don't really need to know if a visitor is a person (or program run by a person), let alone a unique person. The core need is narrower, and involves an accurate floor for how much expense and difficulty the entity will have if they are detected and penalized for breaking social or technological rules. The goal is to exclude the individual heads of a mythological Hydra—but other monsters are fine and can already be handled differently.
We can make a cheaper, faster, and more-private system using "stake" rather than "personhood". For example, a token that can be burned to prove that the bearer paid $5 to a charity, or that someone showed up in person to a location in a way that can't be repeated too often. (E.g. election-ink.)
[0] We should be careful to distinguish between what direct stakeholders require versus what a VC investor requires for their monetization/monopalization business plan.
Many times a simpler system can be made by relaxing unnecessary [0] requirements, and I think this is one of those cases.
Many sites don't really need to know if a visitor is a person (or program run by a person), let alone a unique person. The core need is narrower, and involves an accurate floor for how much expense and difficulty the entity will have if they are detected and penalized for breaking social or technological rules. The goal is to exclude the individual heads of a mythological Hydra—but other monsters are fine and can already be handled differently.
We can make a cheaper, faster, and more-private system using "stake" rather than "personhood". For example, a token that can be burned to prove that the bearer paid $5 to a charity, or that someone showed up in person to a location in a way that can't be repeated too often. (E.g. election-ink.)
[0] We should be careful to distinguish between what direct stakeholders require versus what a VC investor requires for their monetization/monopalization business plan.