I firmly believe that no one should have singular control over a large fraction of feeds.
Media control is by far the easiest way to subvert democratic principles, and all the consolidation and centralization (I'm not blaming anyone for this, I consider it a direct consequence of market dynamics) has enabled a concentration of media power that was completely unthinkable int he newspaper age.
IF you really can't avoid it though, giving your local democratic government control seems the least bad option.
The problem is that given the EU chatcontrol track record and related attempts to introduce limitless surveillance measures maybe leaving China or anyone else in control does not sound such a bad idea...
Everything involving "control" and "children" is by now just a random pile of lies.
You can fill a feed with nothing but the truth and still bias its consumers into whichever direction you want. And in a democracy (or even a nondemocratic state, to a certain degree), that bias directly translates into legislative power once your "customer" base is sufficiently large.
If there is any ovesight at all over how a feed is constructed, then they won't be able to 'fill a feed' with whatever they want.
Gov. can do things like 'user must follow creator to see content', 'content cannot be weighted on subject type'. Algo managers may not take directives from foreign sttage agenices. Algorithm and all details must be made public quarterly. Myst report all alteratios reuired by state agencies for security etc. (aka when fbi asks FB to take down content, that's fine, but the record has to be made avail to regulators).
The companies themselves don't care. Elon wants to push himself, the CCP whats to promote their agenda. But TikTok just wants to make money.
These companies are fine with regs if it helps them push back on 'interfering outside interests'.
It's possible, but would take some thoughtful legislation. Not holding my breath.
Ideally we should have a competitive market where I can choose whether I want the china-controlled algorithm, the EU-controlled algorithm, or some unregulated algorith. Being locked-in to a single option is a big problem.
I don't believe any government should control algorithms, although they can certainly regulate them or require more transparency. However, non-European entities could use their control over them with negative consequences for the EU and its citizens, which I think is why a disinvestment is one possible way to prohibit that.
Ideally, people can choose their own content algorithm (or lack of) with no hijinks or dark patterns around defaults, selection, etc. Perhaps warnings would have to be put in place on certain algorithms, similar to a "contains excess amounts of sugar" warning or so. And some education to go with it. Second most ideal would probably be democratic oversight with reasonable rules in place, as long as the democracy is functioning. Then probably banning it, though that's a bit of a can of worms. Last place is surely people like Zuckerberg controlling it. Really anything is better than what we have now.
Ok, but this is just a statement, not a viable plan for actually running these platforms. It's clear how private tech companies are incentivized to run them, it's unproven but comprehensible how the state could be incentivized to run them.
No one has demonstrated that there's even a coherent plan to get decentralized, sovereign social media off the ground beyond just expecting millions of people to spontaneously become extremely principled. On the contrary, all the evidence throughout the history of the internet is that people will give up almost any power they have in exchange for temporary subsidies and convenience.
Never better than a bunch of robber barons? Never better than totally unregulated medicine? Never better than totally unregulated banks? Never better than letting people dump their factory's pollution directly into rivers?
The US should then do it for all German automakers in the US market.
And then for Airbus in the US market.
And then for ASML, ARM, SAP in the US market.
And then for LVMH and L'Oreal in the US market.
And then for Novo Nordisk in the US market.
And they should be required to turn over all IP for their US satellite companies. All brands related to eg LVMH and L'Oreal in the US are to be controlled by the US.
Yes that's the problem you get when you refuse to cooperate internationally and put up trade barriers. Trade barriers are essentially governments (trying to) tax the people of different countries. It never works, it just leads to breakdowns and sometimes to war. Worst outcomes are seen when people try to use trade barriers to stop war, which often intensifies them.
Mostly they are implemented to maintain balance of trade, in a less visible way that dumping the currency. Of course, like many people before them, the EU is trying to use them as a tool to force global policy. From trying to force an end to the Ukraine war to improving the treatment of pigs, as well as the naming of meat products in China, and everything in between.
And despite what happened with the current president, there are many more trade barriers in Europe (and in fact most countries worldwide, although the EU is really trying hard), especially before, but also after Trump's tariffs.
Europe has created the failed experiment “USA” and will still thrive thousands of years after mankind has forgotten a “USA” once existed. With China, Japan, and all other real countries.
A group of Europeans, later called Americans, created the USA, and 250 years later it is by the most successful country in the world by every real metric. A far greater success story than any of the failed midwit socioeconomic experiments the continentals have come up with during the last two centuries, which all ended up in poverty and war.
Aside from avoiding propaganda, it's completely reasonable to want "the algorithm" to be based on local/geographic boundaries or people you might encounter in real life. Clustering people who can influence each other is often related to political boundaries, but there are many other ones as well. Social networks got this graph "for free" but TikTok is missing a strong social graph, so it's this debate is extra-important for TikTok. I think end-users and public policy should have an explicit role in picking their "community", rather than ML only.
No, TikTok is Chinese and I just picked one example which people are already terrified of. I could have chosen the US but then I'd have to explain more things.
Because they have an unelected government with no limits to the power of its leaders.
I don't particularly like Trump but I've just witnessed the American public exercise controls that limit his power via the mid-term elections.
I have no such hope that anyone can limit what Xi does, or even publicly declare that they dislike any of his policies.
I might revise my view when I see newspapers in China say they've had enough of Xi's rule. Or when some branch of government in China blocks one of his edicts. Or when some rival is able to peacefully force him to step down ignoring his chosen line of succession. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it though.
I am of course concerned about mining user data for the above reasons (and that's in partly why I don't use social media and neither should you - have you deleted your account yet?) but with TikTok specifically the concern is that algorithms and content can be used either overtly or covertly to influence opinion in a way that harms our national interest and our democracy (2016, 2022, Woke, BLM, MAGA, DSA, COVID-19/anti-vax) and we know that this is true and a real concern because China has themselves banned foreign companies from being able to operate unfettered in the same way in their country. If for no other reason than it's not fair we should not (and we don't anymore because we forced the sale) let TikTok operate in our country while they ban our social media platforms. Fair is fair.
If Americans decide that an American company has done something bad we just go shut the company down, arrest whoever we decide to arrest, and that's that. We can require that the American company follow certain rules or legislation, and we can take other action as we see fit. We can't do the same with a company that's not based in the United States nor necessarily bound by our laws or inspectable to the same extent.
I'm not sure why folks keep rehashing and misconstruing this. Even this example of Mining user data... is inaccurate and misses the point.
> If Americans decide that an American company has done something bad we just go shut the company down, arrest whoever we decide to arrest, and that's that.
Sounds fantastical. Some Enron guys went to jail 30 years ago, not a whole lot since.
It's not fantastical - we just have decided for one reason or another not to do anything about "whatever" since then. But if we decide we want to, then we'll do something.
The alternative viewpoint which is that our ability to do so is fantastical just strips away your own agency and in which case well there's nothing for me to do or care about since you've told me that having power or our society "doing something" is just a fantasy.
Ehm sorry, who is "we"? Are we talking about Germans or Austrians? No I can assure you mining data always has been seen very negatively in the German post war history. Are we talking about EU? According to HN GDPR always be a pain in the ass destroying the chance of data mining start ups in the EU.
But my guess: post is from USAian who somehow assumes the USA is the "normal" and Germany or the EU are basically the same. Quiet ironic then to complain about orientalism.
I remember when there was only two government TV channels and a few government radio channels. That brain washing did massive damage to generations of people. Real humans, not tax-payer units or trench warfare filling units, as European leaders and hackers mostly see the European men, women and children as being.
It's not 1916 anymore. Hasn't been for a while. Not only have the "drown government in a bathtub" people had their say, they have had been in charge for 50 years. They have ripped up antitrust, ripped up industrial policy, thoroughly instilled a culture of learned helplessness when it comes to government intervention, and every year borrowed more money to deliver more ultra-regressive tax cuts to their own pockets. This did not result in individual flourishing and freedom maximization, it resulted in asset prices pumped into the stratosphere and wages into the dumpster.
We are sick and tired of it and our next step needs to be a move back towards the type of goverment that can take misbehaving companies over the knee, deliver the ass-whooping they deserve, "now pull up your pants and pay your taxes."
The GDPR's primary purpose is to protect consumers by threat of fines to those that breach the consumers' rights, it's not an embedded device that can be slapped onto a server.
They’ve already fined Tiktok but the threat still exists. And it always will because GDPR conflicts with Chinese law which Chinese companies will follow over GDPR.
surely people understand that if you give the EU control over social media algorithms they would use that to influence elections in favour of their preferred parties right? is that something we want?
"According to the report, officials and activists in Brussels coordinated their efforts down to the last detail. The goal was to win over the public to the EU's climate policy—and in return, millions in taxpayer money were funneled into the effort."
I can give you dozens of examples. Thanks to people like you, we'll never get rid of this undemocratic construct called the European Commission.
edit:
That's not to say I'm against climate protection. But when the EU colludes with activists to manipulate public opinion in a desired direction, this also influences voting behavior - or rather, leads to a shift in power within the public discourse. This goes against our understanding of how a democracy functions. Even the Constitutional Court states that public opinion is formed from the bottom up and is not dictated from above.
given that america just extorted it from the chinese, is the idea that every political unit of sufficient size just have its own tiktok where users can be protected from that dastardly foreign propaganda and only exposed to wholesome, local, pre-approved truth?
Yes, that is what governments of any size want. The larger ones will get it.
Governments think of themselves as the final rule-makers for their subjects. It is offensive to the government of France that someone in Beijing or Washington DC or San Jose CA could make a decision that impacts Frenchmen without their permission.
If you like the people running a government, you are likely to agree with their assertion that they need control. If you dislike them, you are likely to see them as petty tyrants.
Governments will start by insisting that platforms follow their laws everywhere on earth. That isn't going to last, because the 40+ relevant countries will choose rules that contradict each other.
The end-state is a per-country version of every "international" product. Tiktok in the US is a separate platform from Tiktok in China. When France decides that search engines can't link to sporting events without permission, only the French version of Google will do so. If Australia decides that news aggregators must pay to link to a news story, only the Australian version of a news aggregator will do so.
If we're gonna have algorithmic recommendation, then that end state seems... kinda fair?
Why shouldn't a democratically elected Austrian government get to decide how the algo for the Austrian people that elected it works? Why should that be determined by some dude in California that has zero democratic backing? It seems to me as an almost-imperial paternalistic arrogance to be like "no, we know what's best for you and you don't get to decide how things work in your country".
We've seen the corrosive effects online platforms have on society. We've increasingly seen both China and Americans actively wield it as a weapon to hurt our self-determination.
Why should we let them?
Of course, this doesn't need to mean direct government control over algorithms. But one could set up relevant institutions that are outside the immediate grasp of party politics while still maintaining a local perspective. We could take public broadcasters like the BBC, ARD or ORF as model. Would it be perfect? No. But it still seems better than Bytedance, Zuck and Elon in control of digital town squares.
Because people in Austria freely choose to go for the recommendations from some dude in California.
You are touching on the most basic divide between Europe and America, which is freedom vs democracy, or free market vs communism, or individualism vs socialism. Broadly speaking Europeans (and many other cultures) have mostly followed socialism/democracy/communism, while Americans (and some other cultures have mostly followed freedom/free market/individualism.
The guy in California really has no control whatsoever, because each and every user of his application/platform uses it from their own free will and can choose not to use it. In free society / free market, you choose what you use and do. Instead of the government deciding what is best for you and what is best for the "common good".
Hackers and Europeans don't see things in that way. Instead they consider every human besides themselves and the elected politicians to be pawns without any will of their own, being swept hither and tither and in great need for guidance and control from the elected government, which democratically decides what is best for everybody. With this mindset it is not possible to imagine that somebody uses TikTok of their own free will, and every person becomes a victim in everything they do unless the government steps in.
This completely ignores the manipulative nature of social media.
I have worked for a social media company. I know the metrics they optimize for. They specifically optimize for engagement, or in other words, for manipulating users through outrage and emotional manipulation to spend as much of their mental energy as possible on their platform.
In addition, it completely ignores second order effects. If the boomers spend all their time on X, who's owner endorsed the local neofascist party and then end bringing fascism back to Germany, all of Europe gets to pay the price.
This isn't some harmless pastime. It is an algorithmically optimized propaganda platform run by people explicitly seeking out to disrupt our societies.
We don't let people take crack through their own free will, because it is bad for them and bad for society. I don't see how this is any different. The individual freedom angle seems incredibly naive to how the world works at best, actively malicious at worst to me.
Even on its own merits, your argument is deeply flawed. The boomer might prefer the propaganda feed he gets from Elon or Musk. He might not. He hasn't been given the choice. Ironically, your proposal is reducing the options available for consumers!
> This completely ignores the manipulative nature of social media.
It ignores the manipulative nature of all media and of a lot of human communication. You can't get away from that no matter how you regulate or arrange things. Unless we're traveling into Utopia territory.
> the local neofascist party
Ah, never mind.
In a few years you might read your own comment again and the terms you use, and ask yourself if you were the one who had been propagandized. Or at least as much as the straw man "boomer" you are concerned about, but cannot hide your hatred for.
> The boomer might prefer the propaganda feed he gets from Elon or Musk. He might not. He hasn't been given the choice.
He has the choice to turn on the government radio or TV. They're still on air.
> It ignores the manipulative nature of all media and of a lot of human communication. You can't get away from that no matter how you regulate or arrange things. Unless we're traveling into Utopia territory.
Indeed. So why should we give that power to some dude in California or Texas instead of our own population again?
> In a few years you might read your own comment again and the terms you use, and ask yourself if you were the one who had been propagandized. Or at least as much as the straw man "boomer" you are concerned about, but cannot hide your hatred for.
I base my assessment on direct quotes from leadership figures in the party, which I have translated for the benefit of non-German-speakers here:
"We must proceed completely peacefully and deliberately, adapt if necessary and butter up the opponent [literally: smear honey on their mouths], but when we are finally ready, we will put them all against the wall. (...) Dig a pit, all in and quicklime on top."
-- Holger Arppe, former AfD Vice Chair [0]
"The worse Germany is doing, the better it is for the AfD. [...] Therefore we have to consider a tactic between: How bad can things get for Germany? And: How much can we provoke? [...] Because then the AfD does better. We can always just shoot them all later. That's not an issue at all. Or gas them, or however you want. I don't care!"
-- Christian Lüth, AfD Press spokesman [1]
"It doesn't matter, nothing will change, even if we were to eat chalk [act harmless]. Even if we said: yes, we are separating from X, Y and Z now and acting moderate here."
You tell me whether the terms I use are appropriate or not and who's been propagandized.
> He has the choice to turn on the government radio or TV. They're still on air.
Not government radio, specifically. Do reread my earlier comments on institutional setup. And as we both know, they're much less addictive and engagement-optimized than social media. That's precisely the problem.
I have never in my life used Twitter. What control does Elon have over my life? There are thousands of other ways to communicate and publish. We (well some of us) have the freedom to choose what we use and what we do. Others I guess will have to wait for a glorious politician to step down from high heaven and regulate.
Elon himself is a glorious politician sent from heaven. You think that guy doesn't have political goals of his own?
And whether you use it or not, your neighbors are. You are not the only person that affects outcomes for you, you have to see how that is a ridiculous position to take unless you are a hermit somewhere.
You think the social tensions of the past ten years just happened to coincide with mass propagation of social media? C'mon.
He surely might be. But he can't force anybody to use Twitter and he cannot ban speech on other platforms.
Neither can TikTok decide anything outside of their own platform.
> And whether you use it or not, your neighbors are.
Good for them! I'm not a hacker so I don't think I'm God and can decide what is best for everybody. They can choose for themselves.
> You think the social tensions of the past ten years just happened to coincide with mass propagation of social media? C'mon.
It happened because finally people were able to have a voice - for good or for bad, but mostly for good. That's the price of freedom. I remember very well when only a few people had any voice at all. Step out of line in any way and there were consequences to pay. Between a one-sided tyranny of thought to polarization and social tension, I will always select the latter option.
This is a little bit like "a religion of peace", which is true because if you disturb the peace they chop your head off, so nobody does. I prefer freedom.
> Good for them! [...] They can choose for themselves.
It is very telling how you have picked out every part of this comment except ... the core of the argument.
Again, your entire position only makes sense if you're a hermit in a cave somewhere. If you live in a society, what other people do affects you as well. It's not just "good for them", it is also bad for you.
You cannot avoid this simple fact, and the fact that you are avoiding even acknowledging it paints the picture of somebody desperately trying to hold on to their ideological priors.
> I don't think I'm God and can decide what is best for everybody
Again, also not what I propose. Please reread the earlier comment to see my comments on institutional setup, don't just shadowbox a strawman.
>Why shouldn't a democratically elected Austrian government get to decide how the algo for the Austrian people that elected it works?
Then Austrians shouldn't go to the American or Chinese web platform if they don't like that. They can go to ORF and get served exclusively the propaganda of their own government. Why must a website hosted in another country be bound by rules of Austria if Austrians voluntarily choose to go there. When Austrian tourists travel aboard, Austrian government doesn't make demands to theos countries enforce Austrian law.
Try using Google's services like YouTube, or Facebook in China without a VPN. Hell, we don't even get the same TikTok that their citizens get. They were very careful to make sure that Western influences didn't find their way over via social media.
Ok, so are we going to live just like in China minus affordable rent, manufacturing jobs, frontier AI, high-speed rail, good food, etc.? It's a hard sell if you start employing whataboutism.
Preventing foreign powers from deliberately manipulating your society and political discourse is obviously the same as adopting China's censorship regime. Never mind that China has a history of strict censorship going back thousands of years. It's hardly anything new.
I don't want governments deciding what people are allowed to believe. But I also don't want foreign states or unscrupulous corporations deliberately poisoning public discourse, any more than I want them poisoning our drinking water.
Apparently, distinguishing between those two things is a difficult concept for some.
why should we prevent foreign powers from "deliberately manipulating your society and political discourse" but accept that from domestic powers? my issue isn't that i trust the chinese government, it's that i distrust american government as much as i distrust the chinese government and the current way that the american government deals with tiktok propaganda isn't by providing some sort of neutral-by-default playing field, it's by seizing the network and flooding it with their own propaganda.
You'll also notice that there's no real effort to do this with services hosted outside of China. It's almost like the PRC has a long and storied history of hacking Western targets and they've earned a reputation as a result.
VKontakte didn't manage to gain ground in Europe, though, and they possibly didn't even try. They weren't a threat to the status quo. Only TikTok is, and look at the gov't reaction.
It's reasonable not to want foreign powers with a clear interest in destabilizing your society and influencing your politics to have unrestricted influence over one of your largest social media platforms.
There should be ways to address that concern without resorting to government control over what people are allowed to believe.
Yes those are the only two options. Censorship or no censorship.
Preventing anybody, even those evil foreigners you don't like having "influence"
(whatever that means? I assume you mean providing information you don't consider to be true?)
That's censorship.
Sure, let's pretend state propaganda and the well-documented(even by platforms itself) manipulation of public discourse by social media don't exist. That should make them disappear.
Propaganda is not working with the truth. It's deliberate proven effective tactic used, again, for thousand of year's. It sadly is not an academic debate.
So your population is mentally deficient and you are paternalistically (maternalistically in the case here I suppose) protecting them? Like small children?
Yes just the society I want, psychopathic corrupt politicians pretending to be my mother.
You're just upset your society doesn't have the ability to compete anymore on this front.
I firmly believe that no one should have singular control over a large fraction of feeds.
Media control is by far the easiest way to subvert democratic principles, and all the consolidation and centralization (I'm not blaming anyone for this, I consider it a direct consequence of market dynamics) has enabled a concentration of media power that was completely unthinkable int he newspaper age.
IF you really can't avoid it though, giving your local democratic government control seems the least bad option.
The problem is that given the EU chatcontrol track record and related attempts to introduce limitless surveillance measures maybe leaving China or anyone else in control does not sound such a bad idea... Everything involving "control" and "children" is by now just a random pile of lies.
Regulations are by far superior to state control.
State agencies are notoriously terrible at all of these things.
How would you even regulate power?
You can fill a feed with nothing but the truth and still bias its consumers into whichever direction you want. And in a democracy (or even a nondemocratic state, to a certain degree), that bias directly translates into legislative power once your "customer" base is sufficiently large.
If there is any ovesight at all over how a feed is constructed, then they won't be able to 'fill a feed' with whatever they want.
Gov. can do things like 'user must follow creator to see content', 'content cannot be weighted on subject type'. Algo managers may not take directives from foreign sttage agenices. Algorithm and all details must be made public quarterly. Myst report all alteratios reuired by state agencies for security etc. (aka when fbi asks FB to take down content, that's fine, but the record has to be made avail to regulators).
The companies themselves don't care. Elon wants to push himself, the CCP whats to promote their agenda. But TikTok just wants to make money.
These companies are fine with regs if it helps them push back on 'interfering outside interests'.
It's possible, but would take some thoughtful legislation. Not holding my breath.
The US did it with TikTok, so why shouldn't the EU also do it for TikTok, Instagram, FaceBook, etc.
Honestly every country should be have massive oversight, if not outright control, over the algorithm at the very least.
Ideally we should have a competitive market where I can choose whether I want the china-controlled algorithm, the EU-controlled algorithm, or some unregulated algorith. Being locked-in to a single option is a big problem.
These are highly addictive products. Competition is good when you want a lot of something. Maybe not the best goal here.
I don't believe any government should control algorithms, although they can certainly regulate them or require more transparency. However, non-European entities could use their control over them with negative consequences for the EU and its citizens, which I think is why a disinvestment is one possible way to prohibit that.
Regulate yes, control no
Sounds like op. Freedom of speech can be controlled if you control the algorithm.
Unless you adopt my preferred solution of banning content algorithms, someone is going to control it. Better a bunch of bureaucrats than Zuckerberg.
Ideally, people can choose their own content algorithm (or lack of) with no hijinks or dark patterns around defaults, selection, etc. Perhaps warnings would have to be put in place on certain algorithms, similar to a "contains excess amounts of sugar" warning or so. And some education to go with it. Second most ideal would probably be democratic oversight with reasonable rules in place, as long as the democracy is functioning. Then probably banning it, though that's a bit of a can of worms. Last place is surely people like Zuckerberg controlling it. Really anything is better than what we have now.
My poor mans version of this has been to get off those platforms and instead use RSS.
> Ideally
Ok, but this is just a statement, not a viable plan for actually running these platforms. It's clear how private tech companies are incentivized to run them, it's unproven but comprehensible how the state could be incentivized to run them.
No one has demonstrated that there's even a coherent plan to get decentralized, sovereign social media off the ground beyond just expecting millions of people to spontaneously become extremely principled. On the contrary, all the evidence throughout the history of the internet is that people will give up almost any power they have in exchange for temporary subsidies and convenience.
> Better a bunch of bureaucrats
Bureaucrats controlling anything has never been "better" than any other option. Only more expensive.
Never better than a bunch of robber barons? Never better than totally unregulated medicine? Never better than totally unregulated banks? Never better than letting people dump their factory's pollution directly into rivers?
I question that.
The US should then do it for all German automakers in the US market.
And then for Airbus in the US market.
And then for ASML, ARM, SAP in the US market.
And then for LVMH and L'Oreal in the US market.
And then for Novo Nordisk in the US market.
And they should be required to turn over all IP for their US satellite companies. All brands related to eg LVMH and L'Oreal in the US are to be controlled by the US.
Yes that's the problem you get when you refuse to cooperate internationally and put up trade barriers. Trade barriers are essentially governments (trying to) tax the people of different countries. It never works, it just leads to breakdowns and sometimes to war. Worst outcomes are seen when people try to use trade barriers to stop war, which often intensifies them.
Mostly they are implemented to maintain balance of trade, in a less visible way that dumping the currency. Of course, like many people before them, the EU is trying to use them as a tool to force global policy. From trying to force an end to the Ukraine war to improving the treatment of pigs, as well as the naming of meat products in China, and everything in between.
And despite what happened with the current president, there are many more trade barriers in Europe (and in fact most countries worldwide, although the EU is really trying hard), especially before, but also after Trump's tariffs.
Europe has created the failed experiment “USA” and will still thrive thousands of years after mankind has forgotten a “USA” once existed. With China, Japan, and all other real countries.
These are all schoolyard quarrels.
Don't worry, the EU tried to shut it back down. I hear some people disagreed though.
A group of Europeans, later called Americans, created the USA, and 250 years later it is by the most successful country in the world by every real metric. A far greater success story than any of the failed midwit socioeconomic experiments the continentals have come up with during the last two centuries, which all ended up in poverty and war.
20% of the US population were enslaved.
One of the US main exports is war.
No question that the US is the global hegemon.
Rome too looked successful at the time.
Europe is intent on becoming an irrelevant museum that makes cheese and shows off the greatness of their past to tourists.
Yes, lets take back global economy to the cold war days, without offshoring, and proper sovereignty.
Yeah, the US strongarmed the tiktok sale fair and square, how dare those Euros try something so dastardly.
China censors it's internet, why shouldn't the EU do it too?
Most Chinese people don’t seem to mind it that much
How would you know?
They do
You mean Israel did it. Trump gave it straight to Ellison.
Social media is toxic for teenagers. Banning smartphones in Austrian schools is a good first step.
Honestly, I have never met anyone who spent hours mindlessly scrolling through social media and came away feeling that they had just had a great time.
Aside from avoiding propaganda, it's completely reasonable to want "the algorithm" to be based on local/geographic boundaries or people you might encounter in real life. Clustering people who can influence each other is often related to political boundaries, but there are many other ones as well. Social networks got this graph "for free" but TikTok is missing a strong social graph, so it's this debate is extra-important for TikTok. I think end-users and public policy should have an explicit role in picking their "community", rather than ML only.
Meanwhile data brokers exist, and can have Chinese owners.
They should address user tracking more broadly.
I’m pretty sure the EU already addresses user tracking more thoroughly than any country on the planet
Yes, we’re all much safer with cookie banners.
I take it you consider China a worse or more dangerous actor than other countries presumably including the US. Why?
No, TikTok is Chinese and I just picked one example which people are already terrified of. I could have chosen the US but then I'd have to explain more things.
> Why?
Because they have an unelected government with no limits to the power of its leaders.
I don't particularly like Trump but I've just witnessed the American public exercise controls that limit his power via the mid-term elections.
I have no such hope that anyone can limit what Xi does, or even publicly declare that they dislike any of his policies.
I might revise my view when I see newspapers in China say they've had enough of Xi's rule. Or when some branch of government in China blocks one of his edicts. Or when some rival is able to peacefully force him to step down ignoring his chosen line of succession. I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for it though.
Mining user data for manipulation and tracking: Great part of the free market!
Mining user data for manipulation and tracking(Chinese-style): Greatest threat to man kind!
(aware that's not what you're saying but it makes me very mad that we only care about privacy when its combined with orientalism)
I am of course concerned about mining user data for the above reasons (and that's in partly why I don't use social media and neither should you - have you deleted your account yet?) but with TikTok specifically the concern is that algorithms and content can be used either overtly or covertly to influence opinion in a way that harms our national interest and our democracy (2016, 2022, Woke, BLM, MAGA, DSA, COVID-19/anti-vax) and we know that this is true and a real concern because China has themselves banned foreign companies from being able to operate unfettered in the same way in their country. If for no other reason than it's not fair we should not (and we don't anymore because we forced the sale) let TikTok operate in our country while they ban our social media platforms. Fair is fair.
If Americans decide that an American company has done something bad we just go shut the company down, arrest whoever we decide to arrest, and that's that. We can require that the American company follow certain rules or legislation, and we can take other action as we see fit. We can't do the same with a company that's not based in the United States nor necessarily bound by our laws or inspectable to the same extent.
I'm not sure why folks keep rehashing and misconstruing this. Even this example of Mining user data... is inaccurate and misses the point.
> If Americans decide that an American company has done something bad we just go shut the company down, arrest whoever we decide to arrest, and that's that.
Sounds fantastical. Some Enron guys went to jail 30 years ago, not a whole lot since.
It's not fantastical - we just have decided for one reason or another not to do anything about "whatever" since then. But if we decide we want to, then we'll do something.
The alternative viewpoint which is that our ability to do so is fantastical just strips away your own agency and in which case well there's nothing for me to do or care about since you've told me that having power or our society "doing something" is just a fantasy.
Ehm sorry, who is "we"? Are we talking about Germans or Austrians? No I can assure you mining data always has been seen very negatively in the German post war history. Are we talking about EU? According to HN GDPR always be a pain in the ass destroying the chance of data mining start ups in the EU.
But my guess: post is from USAian who somehow assumes the USA is the "normal" and Germany or the EU are basically the same. Quiet ironic then to complain about orientalism.
Previous discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50549548
Then Facebook, YouTube and instagram. It’s time “take back control”!
I remember when there was only two government TV channels and a few government radio channels. That brain washing did massive damage to generations of people. Real humans, not tax-payer units or trench warfare filling units, as European leaders and hackers mostly see the European men, women and children as being.
It's not 1916 anymore. Hasn't been for a while. Not only have the "drown government in a bathtub" people had their say, they have had been in charge for 50 years. They have ripped up antitrust, ripped up industrial policy, thoroughly instilled a culture of learned helplessness when it comes to government intervention, and every year borrowed more money to deliver more ultra-regressive tax cuts to their own pockets. This did not result in individual flourishing and freedom maximization, it resulted in asset prices pumped into the stratosphere and wages into the dumpster.
We are sick and tired of it and our next step needs to be a move back towards the type of goverment that can take misbehaving companies over the knee, deliver the ass-whooping they deserve, "now pull up your pants and pay your taxes."
If the US can make the claim so can Europe.
OK so I have no problem with the initiative.
But let's clarify something here:
>Both officials pointed to the uncertainty surrounding the Chinese government’s potential access to European user data, given ByteDance’s origins.
This is fully protected by GDPR already. In theory. In practice GDPR cannot and has not stopped it.
The GDPR's primary purpose is to protect consumers by threat of fines to those that breach the consumers' rights, it's not an embedded device that can be slapped onto a server.
They’ve already fined Tiktok but the threat still exists. And it always will because GDPR conflicts with Chinese law which Chinese companies will follow over GDPR.
surely people understand that if you give the EU control over social media algorithms they would use that to influence elections in favour of their preferred parties right? is that something we want?
Can you give a few examples where the EU did "influence elections in favour of their preferred parties"?
https://www.tagesschau.de/ausland/europa/eu-kommission-bezah...
"According to the report, officials and activists in Brussels coordinated their efforts down to the last detail. The goal was to win over the public to the EU's climate policy—and in return, millions in taxpayer money were funneled into the effort."
I can give you dozens of examples. Thanks to people like you, we'll never get rid of this undemocratic construct called the European Commission.
edit: That's not to say I'm against climate protection. But when the EU colludes with activists to manipulate public opinion in a desired direction, this also influences voting behavior - or rather, leads to a shift in power within the public discourse. This goes against our understanding of how a democracy functions. Even the Constitutional Court states that public opinion is formed from the bottom up and is not dictated from above.
That's right, it's very important that Zuckerberg and Musk get to pick European leaders instead!
Do this also for Meta Platforms
Or is the EU parliment afraid of the US?
but what about ...
We should not stop there.
We should force Europe to turn over all control of all of their companies within the US market to the US, including all intellectual property.
its banned in india
Great, now I can get curated American propaganda
given that america just extorted it from the chinese, is the idea that every political unit of sufficient size just have its own tiktok where users can be protected from that dastardly foreign propaganda and only exposed to wholesome, local, pre-approved truth?
Yes, that is what governments of any size want. The larger ones will get it.
Governments think of themselves as the final rule-makers for their subjects. It is offensive to the government of France that someone in Beijing or Washington DC or San Jose CA could make a decision that impacts Frenchmen without their permission.
If you like the people running a government, you are likely to agree with their assertion that they need control. If you dislike them, you are likely to see them as petty tyrants.
Governments will start by insisting that platforms follow their laws everywhere on earth. That isn't going to last, because the 40+ relevant countries will choose rules that contradict each other.
The end-state is a per-country version of every "international" product. Tiktok in the US is a separate platform from Tiktok in China. When France decides that search engines can't link to sporting events without permission, only the French version of Google will do so. If Australia decides that news aggregators must pay to link to a news story, only the Australian version of a news aggregator will do so.
If we're gonna have algorithmic recommendation, then that end state seems... kinda fair?
Why shouldn't a democratically elected Austrian government get to decide how the algo for the Austrian people that elected it works? Why should that be determined by some dude in California that has zero democratic backing? It seems to me as an almost-imperial paternalistic arrogance to be like "no, we know what's best for you and you don't get to decide how things work in your country".
We've seen the corrosive effects online platforms have on society. We've increasingly seen both China and Americans actively wield it as a weapon to hurt our self-determination.
Why should we let them?
Of course, this doesn't need to mean direct government control over algorithms. But one could set up relevant institutions that are outside the immediate grasp of party politics while still maintaining a local perspective. We could take public broadcasters like the BBC, ARD or ORF as model. Would it be perfect? No. But it still seems better than Bytedance, Zuck and Elon in control of digital town squares.
Because people in Austria freely choose to go for the recommendations from some dude in California.
You are touching on the most basic divide between Europe and America, which is freedom vs democracy, or free market vs communism, or individualism vs socialism. Broadly speaking Europeans (and many other cultures) have mostly followed socialism/democracy/communism, while Americans (and some other cultures have mostly followed freedom/free market/individualism.
The guy in California really has no control whatsoever, because each and every user of his application/platform uses it from their own free will and can choose not to use it. In free society / free market, you choose what you use and do. Instead of the government deciding what is best for you and what is best for the "common good".
Hackers and Europeans don't see things in that way. Instead they consider every human besides themselves and the elected politicians to be pawns without any will of their own, being swept hither and tither and in great need for guidance and control from the elected government, which democratically decides what is best for everybody. With this mindset it is not possible to imagine that somebody uses TikTok of their own free will, and every person becomes a victim in everything they do unless the government steps in.
This completely ignores the manipulative nature of social media.
I have worked for a social media company. I know the metrics they optimize for. They specifically optimize for engagement, or in other words, for manipulating users through outrage and emotional manipulation to spend as much of their mental energy as possible on their platform.
In addition, it completely ignores second order effects. If the boomers spend all their time on X, who's owner endorsed the local neofascist party and then end bringing fascism back to Germany, all of Europe gets to pay the price.
This isn't some harmless pastime. It is an algorithmically optimized propaganda platform run by people explicitly seeking out to disrupt our societies.
We don't let people take crack through their own free will, because it is bad for them and bad for society. I don't see how this is any different. The individual freedom angle seems incredibly naive to how the world works at best, actively malicious at worst to me.
Even on its own merits, your argument is deeply flawed. The boomer might prefer the propaganda feed he gets from Elon or Musk. He might not. He hasn't been given the choice. Ironically, your proposal is reducing the options available for consumers!
> This completely ignores the manipulative nature of social media.
It ignores the manipulative nature of all media and of a lot of human communication. You can't get away from that no matter how you regulate or arrange things. Unless we're traveling into Utopia territory.
> the local neofascist party
Ah, never mind.
In a few years you might read your own comment again and the terms you use, and ask yourself if you were the one who had been propagandized. Or at least as much as the straw man "boomer" you are concerned about, but cannot hide your hatred for.
> The boomer might prefer the propaganda feed he gets from Elon or Musk. He might not. He hasn't been given the choice.
He has the choice to turn on the government radio or TV. They're still on air.
> It ignores the manipulative nature of all media and of a lot of human communication. You can't get away from that no matter how you regulate or arrange things. Unless we're traveling into Utopia territory.
Indeed. So why should we give that power to some dude in California or Texas instead of our own population again?
> In a few years you might read your own comment again and the terms you use, and ask yourself if you were the one who had been propagandized. Or at least as much as the straw man "boomer" you are concerned about, but cannot hide your hatred for.
I base my assessment on direct quotes from leadership figures in the party, which I have translated for the benefit of non-German-speakers here:
"We must proceed completely peacefully and deliberately, adapt if necessary and butter up the opponent [literally: smear honey on their mouths], but when we are finally ready, we will put them all against the wall. (...) Dig a pit, all in and quicklime on top."
-- Holger Arppe, former AfD Vice Chair [0]
"The worse Germany is doing, the better it is for the AfD. [...] Therefore we have to consider a tactic between: How bad can things get for Germany? And: How much can we provoke? [...] Because then the AfD does better. We can always just shoot them all later. That's not an issue at all. Or gas them, or however you want. I don't care!"
-- Christian Lüth, AfD Press spokesman [1]
"It doesn't matter, nothing will change, even if we were to eat chalk [act harmless]. Even if we said: yes, we are separating from X, Y and Z now and acting moderate here."
-- Hans-Christoph Berndt, AfD Brandenburg senate leader [2]
You tell me whether the terms I use are appropriate or not and who's been propagandized.
> He has the choice to turn on the government radio or TV. They're still on air.
Not government radio, specifically. Do reread my earlier comments on institutional setup. And as we both know, they're much less addictive and engagement-optimized than social media. That's precisely the problem.
[0] https://taz.de/Frueherer-AfD-Fraktionsvize-verurteilt/!56167...
[1] https://www.tagesspiegel.de/politik/afd-sprecher-wollte-fluc...
[2] https://mik.brandenburg.de/sixcms/media.php/9/Einstufungsver...
> The guy in California really has no control whatsoever
Have you seen what Elon did to twitter?
I have never in my life used Twitter. What control does Elon have over my life? There are thousands of other ways to communicate and publish. We (well some of us) have the freedom to choose what we use and what we do. Others I guess will have to wait for a glorious politician to step down from high heaven and regulate.
It must be nice to not understand how network effects work.
Elon himself is a glorious politician sent from heaven. You think that guy doesn't have political goals of his own?
And whether you use it or not, your neighbors are. You are not the only person that affects outcomes for you, you have to see how that is a ridiculous position to take unless you are a hermit somewhere.
You think the social tensions of the past ten years just happened to coincide with mass propagation of social media? C'mon.
He surely might be. But he can't force anybody to use Twitter and he cannot ban speech on other platforms.
Neither can TikTok decide anything outside of their own platform.
> And whether you use it or not, your neighbors are.
Good for them! I'm not a hacker so I don't think I'm God and can decide what is best for everybody. They can choose for themselves.
> You think the social tensions of the past ten years just happened to coincide with mass propagation of social media? C'mon.
It happened because finally people were able to have a voice - for good or for bad, but mostly for good. That's the price of freedom. I remember very well when only a few people had any voice at all. Step out of line in any way and there were consequences to pay. Between a one-sided tyranny of thought to polarization and social tension, I will always select the latter option.
This is a little bit like "a religion of peace", which is true because if you disturb the peace they chop your head off, so nobody does. I prefer freedom.
> Good for them! [...] They can choose for themselves.
It is very telling how you have picked out every part of this comment except ... the core of the argument.
Again, your entire position only makes sense if you're a hermit in a cave somewhere. If you live in a society, what other people do affects you as well. It's not just "good for them", it is also bad for you.
You cannot avoid this simple fact, and the fact that you are avoiding even acknowledging it paints the picture of somebody desperately trying to hold on to their ideological priors.
> I don't think I'm God and can decide what is best for everybody
Again, also not what I propose. Please reread the earlier comment to see my comments on institutional setup, don't just shadowbox a strawman.
>Why shouldn't a democratically elected Austrian government get to decide how the algo for the Austrian people that elected it works?
Then Austrians shouldn't go to the American or Chinese web platform if they don't like that. They can go to ORF and get served exclusively the propaganda of their own government. Why must a website hosted in another country be bound by rules of Austria if Austrians voluntarily choose to go there. When Austrian tourists travel aboard, Austrian government doesn't make demands to theos countries enforce Austrian law.
That's how China works, why not the West?
Try using Google's services like YouTube, or Facebook in China without a VPN. Hell, we don't even get the same TikTok that their citizens get. They were very careful to make sure that Western influences didn't find their way over via social media.
Ok, so are we going to live just like in China minus affordable rent, manufacturing jobs, frontier AI, high-speed rail, good food, etc.? It's a hard sell if you start employing whataboutism.
This is false dilemma.
Preventing foreign powers from deliberately manipulating your society and political discourse is obviously the same as adopting China's censorship regime. Never mind that China has a history of strict censorship going back thousands of years. It's hardly anything new.
I don't want governments deciding what people are allowed to believe. But I also don't want foreign states or unscrupulous corporations deliberately poisoning public discourse, any more than I want them poisoning our drinking water.
Apparently, distinguishing between those two things is a difficult concept for some.
why should we prevent foreign powers from "deliberately manipulating your society and political discourse" but accept that from domestic powers? my issue isn't that i trust the chinese government, it's that i distrust american government as much as i distrust the chinese government and the current way that the american government deals with tiktok propaganda isn't by providing some sort of neutral-by-default playing field, it's by seizing the network and flooding it with their own propaganda.
Turnabout is fair play.
Take up the rest with your elected leaders.
You'll also notice that there's no real effort to do this with services hosted outside of China. It's almost like the PRC has a long and storied history of hacking Western targets and they've earned a reputation as a result.
Isn't Tiktok literally the first globally relevant non-US social media to even exist?
There have been others; VKontakte is Russian. It's also banned in China.
China can't ban social networks from other countries and then cry foul when the same is done to TikTok.
VKontakte didn't manage to gain ground in Europe, though, and they possibly didn't even try. They weren't a threat to the status quo. Only TikTok is, and look at the gov't reaction.
> It's almost like the PRC has a long and storied history of hacking Western targets and they've earned a reputation as a result.
Stuxnet called, it asked for it's double standard back.
It's reasonable not to want foreign powers with a clear interest in destabilizing your society and influencing your politics to have unrestricted influence over one of your largest social media platforms.
There should be ways to address that concern without resorting to government control over what people are allowed to believe.
Yes those are the only two options. Censorship or no censorship. Preventing anybody, even those evil foreigners you don't like having "influence" (whatever that means? I assume you mean providing information you don't consider to be true?) That's censorship.
Right now there's still censorship, it's just controlled by the US and China.
The influence is obvious, they're literally in control over what billions of people see every day.
TikTok is already a censored platform by its owners; you can't post nudity there.
Sure, let's pretend state propaganda and the well-documented(even by platforms itself) manipulation of public discourse by social media don't exist. That should make them disappear.
we're not here to pretend they don't exist, we're here to not privilege one government's propaganda over another's
It exists quite plainly but your supposed to win because your ideas are better than their slop and your not afraid of it
If your ideas aren't better, Well that when u get nervous isn't it.
Propaganda is not working with the truth. It's deliberate proven effective tactic used, again, for thousand of year's. It sadly is not an academic debate.
So your population is mentally deficient and you are paternalistically (maternalistically in the case here I suppose) protecting them? Like small children? Yes just the society I want, psychopathic corrupt politicians pretending to be my mother.
You're just upset your society doesn't have the ability to compete anymore on this front.