AI is doing the literal opposite though, this is why the whole argument falls flat. I am now doing bigger tasks and carry more responsibility than I ever did. The repetitive tasks are automated in a couple minutes.
How is that different from the second Industrial Revolution with the introduction of machinery? Countless people lost their jobs while those employed had more responsibility piled on and more was expected of them and they were expected to do it all faster… as fast as the machine would go.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen_hypothesis is kind of a play on this. When you step up an economic improvement everyone else will adapt to it and you'll have to adapt further/work harder/spend more energy to stay exactly where you are. This is why your body is more parasites and viruses by cell count than actual human cells.
Now, we can 'all' fight back against AI and stop it, at least in a country or two, but that doesn't mean some other sovereign nation won't be able to pick up the mantel and economically ruin every one else in the medium to long term.
In the computer age but pre-2022, there were a few careers where the means of automation were in the hands of individuals and heavily reduced working time. I enjoyed that for over a decade as a translator whose CAT software's translation memory was enough to automate most of my work; I was only actually working about 2 days a week. Over those years, IT professionals on nerd forums like this reported that they could automate aspects of their contractor work and reduce working hours.
Sure, no gravy train lasts forever, and one had to be running one's own business instead of working for a boss who would siphon off the gains, but there were nevertheless real time-savings from automation.
AI is going to enable all kinds of dystopian bullshit that employees will have to deal with. There is no job or class of worker who will be safe. Ultimately, the best way to deal with this will be to unionize. Companies will do everything in their power to exploit you. The few rights workers have today were fought for by unions against corporations, with violence and loss of life on both sides, and companies have worked tirelessly to erode those rights and weaken the power of the unions that gave us things like weekends and overtime pay. Now it's looking like workers all over the world will need to get ready to fight again.
The problem with unionization is visible in the largely successful union-busting operations of the late 20th century: once companies find alternatives to unionized labor (e.g., automation, foreign labor), unions lose their bargaining power.
The solution is simultaneous unionization together with a government that forces companies to accept the union's terms. We have a name for this: socialism.
Workers of the world, unite. You have nothing to lose but your chains.
>Ultimately, the best way to deal with this will be to unionize.
Maybe, but it's probably already too late for that. Capitalists have so entrenched anti-union propaganda in the American population so thoroughly that it will take a generation or two to overcome.
According to Gallup, 71% of Americans approve of labor unions and 47% want unions to have more influence as of Sept[0]. The tech industry likely trends lower than these averages, but unions are making major inroads in the tech sector today.
taken to the logical extreme, AI represents a hoarding of wealth and power the likes we've never seen before. we will need to reinvent society because traditional capitalistic stances on AI will result in a slave underclass and an ai-controlling overlord class.
A decent proportion of the world's population has lived, or still lives, under communism today.
The ones that didn't nevertheless adopted many "socialist" and labor-friendly ideas such as social insurance, universal healthcare, workers compensation, child labor bans, and weekends and standard workweeks.
Uh, yes, the wealth concentration complaints and talk about extreme class polarization do, in fact, sound exactly like the early communist movements formed by downwardly-mobile craftsmen undergoing proletarianization.
The same people are often saying how AI is going to take over all our work and no one will have a job, but these same people will also say AI isn't intelligence, it has no moat, it has no viable business model, it has hit a wall, etc.
The first is already happening (if you don't notice the layoffs and hiring freezes that's on you).
In the second part you lump some opinions that are not exclusive with the first. Like you can kill jobs and have no viable business model and survivr on VC money so you grow big enough and tie up the entire country's economy in infrastructure projects and get everyone addicted to your piracy machine, so that when circular financing stops working taxpayer money bails you out.
Those aren't incompatible views. We could end up with subpar AI customer service etc. that never reaches AGI, but it's still what our future is and displaces a lot of labor.
And "no viable business model" for the majority of AI companies doesn't mean that there couldn't be a collapse into a small number of ever consolidating, ever enshittifying winning players, like with streaming for example.
This is destructive to the civilization and it must be banned: They are literally using knowledge professions - lawyers, scientists, doctors etc - to train AI with gig work and then both causing them to get laid off and also cutting what the gig work pays.
This is literally decimating the educated workforce that human science and technology relies on. When this workforce is decimated, there won't be anyone producing the next scientific paper. Or, more likely, there will be too few. Human science and technology will get hampered as a result.
I mean... i dream of asking an AI what the code is for making home modifications, and getting a real, legally sound answer. If you ask 30 inspectors and the people who wrote the code, you'll probably get 40 answers.
I do think AI offers a solution to the misinformation problem. The problem is picking the right AI to trust. It probably needs to be open source.
So, uh, why should knowledge professions be exempt from the same process of industrialization and proletarianization that basically all manual crafts went through in the 19th and early 20th centuries?
It wasn't good in the short term but in the long term average quality of life is up massively compared to 100 years ago
Will the same be true this time? Maybe...
I could certainly see AI interesting the rate of scientific breakthroughs and so leading to a technological golden age (room temperature semi conductors, cures for many diseases, quantum computing)
Or it could just lead to mass unemployment and an even bigger wealth gap
In what ways massively? Do you factor in negative externalities like ecosystem damage? Do you differentiate what was improved because of industralization and what would be improved regardless?
Isn't this just industrialization, taking skilled artisan work and turning it into repeatable smaller tasks?
AI is doing the literal opposite though, this is why the whole argument falls flat. I am now doing bigger tasks and carry more responsibility than I ever did. The repetitive tasks are automated in a couple minutes.
How is that different from the second Industrial Revolution with the introduction of machinery? Countless people lost their jobs while those employed had more responsibility piled on and more was expected of them and they were expected to do it all faster… as fast as the machine would go.
The skilled will become even more valuable.
There were people who managed factory lines, worked on factory line engineering, built tools around factory line, etc.
Then there were car sales men, car dealership owners, contractors who built the car dealership buildings, marketing people who marketed the cars, etc.
The economy grew because the factory line made it more efficient to transport from point A to point B and better harness energy to move goods.
When has any automation lead to less work?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Queen_hypothesis is kind of a play on this. When you step up an economic improvement everyone else will adapt to it and you'll have to adapt further/work harder/spend more energy to stay exactly where you are. This is why your body is more parasites and viruses by cell count than actual human cells.
Now, we can 'all' fight back against AI and stop it, at least in a country or two, but that doesn't mean some other sovereign nation won't be able to pick up the mantel and economically ruin every one else in the medium to long term.
> When has any automation lead to less work?
The automobile destroyed the horse job market in the early 20th century. It never recovered.
In the computer age but pre-2022, there were a few careers where the means of automation were in the hands of individuals and heavily reduced working time. I enjoyed that for over a decade as a translator whose CAT software's translation memory was enough to automate most of my work; I was only actually working about 2 days a week. Over those years, IT professionals on nerd forums like this reported that they could automate aspects of their contractor work and reduce working hours.
Sure, no gravy train lasts forever, and one had to be running one's own business instead of working for a boss who would siphon off the gains, but there were nevertheless real time-savings from automation.
That is because, to follow the analogy, you are the person designing/making/selling the industrial machines.
related: restofworld is on the bringe of shutdown: https://www.semafor.com/article/10/25/2026/rest-of-world-fac...
> Rest of World will cease publishing as a standalone entity at the end of January.
AI is going to enable all kinds of dystopian bullshit that employees will have to deal with. There is no job or class of worker who will be safe. Ultimately, the best way to deal with this will be to unionize. Companies will do everything in their power to exploit you. The few rights workers have today were fought for by unions against corporations, with violence and loss of life on both sides, and companies have worked tirelessly to erode those rights and weaken the power of the unions that gave us things like weekends and overtime pay. Now it's looking like workers all over the world will need to get ready to fight again.
The problem with unionization is visible in the largely successful union-busting operations of the late 20th century: once companies find alternatives to unionized labor (e.g., automation, foreign labor), unions lose their bargaining power.
The solution is simultaneous unionization together with a government that forces companies to accept the union's terms. We have a name for this: socialism.
Workers of the world, unite. You have nothing to lose but your chains.
So you're moving all that control to one entity that is backed by the military. How is that better?
AI? Don't you mean technology in general?
>Ultimately, the best way to deal with this will be to unionize.
Maybe, but it's probably already too late for that. Capitalists have so entrenched anti-union propaganda in the American population so thoroughly that it will take a generation or two to overcome.
This isn't true.
According to Gallup, 71% of Americans approve of labor unions and 47% want unions to have more influence as of Sept[0]. The tech industry likely trends lower than these averages, but unions are making major inroads in the tech sector today.
0: https://news.gallup.com/poll/713936/record-high-unions-influ...
"Evolving" labor from skilled individuals into fungible operators of AI is a huge win for management that doesn't take the form of unemployment.
Fungible operators of AI cannot be a valid perspective.
Otherwise managers would be fungible.
Actually, the same skills that make great managers make great AI orchestrators.
Huge wins for management are typically huge losses for everyone else.
taken to the logical extreme, AI represents a hoarding of wealth and power the likes we've never seen before. we will need to reinvent society because traditional capitalistic stances on AI will result in a slave underclass and an ai-controlling overlord class.
Yeah that's what people were saying in 1848 and so far the Industrial Revolution has failed to directly cause a revolutionary transition to communism.
A decent proportion of the world's population has lived, or still lives, under communism today.
The ones that didn't nevertheless adopted many "socialist" and labor-friendly ideas such as social insurance, universal healthcare, workers compensation, child labor bans, and weekends and standard workweeks.
Yeah, right on. What's happening right now is exactly the same as what happened in 1848
Uh, yes, the wealth concentration complaints and talk about extreme class polarization do, in fact, sound exactly like the early communist movements formed by downwardly-mobile craftsmen undergoing proletarianization.
“Repetitive” jobs are being replaced, and the rest are being made repetitive.
The duality of AI opinions.
The same people are often saying how AI is going to take over all our work and no one will have a job, but these same people will also say AI isn't intelligence, it has no moat, it has no viable business model, it has hit a wall, etc.
The first is already happening (if you don't notice the layoffs and hiring freezes that's on you).
In the second part you lump some opinions that are not exclusive with the first. Like you can kill jobs and have no viable business model and survivr on VC money so you grow big enough and tie up the entire country's economy in infrastructure projects and get everyone addicted to your piracy machine, so that when circular financing stops working taxpayer money bails you out.
Those aren't incompatible views. We could end up with subpar AI customer service etc. that never reaches AGI, but it's still what our future is and displaces a lot of labor.
And "no viable business model" for the majority of AI companies doesn't mean that there couldn't be a collapse into a small number of ever consolidating, ever enshittifying winning players, like with streaming for example.
That is the dream.
This is destructive to the civilization and it must be banned: They are literally using knowledge professions - lawyers, scientists, doctors etc - to train AI with gig work and then both causing them to get laid off and also cutting what the gig work pays.
This is literally decimating the educated workforce that human science and technology relies on. When this workforce is decimated, there won't be anyone producing the next scientific paper. Or, more likely, there will be too few. Human science and technology will get hampered as a result.
I mean... i dream of asking an AI what the code is for making home modifications, and getting a real, legally sound answer. If you ask 30 inspectors and the people who wrote the code, you'll probably get 40 answers.
I do think AI offers a solution to the misinformation problem. The problem is picking the right AI to trust. It probably needs to be open source.
So, uh, why should knowledge professions be exempt from the same process of industrialization and proletarianization that basically all manual crafts went through in the 19th and early 20th centuries?
Was it good and for whom? Now using your own parallel how do you imagine the same will go with knowledge and with what results?
It wasn't good in the short term but in the long term average quality of life is up massively compared to 100 years ago
Will the same be true this time? Maybe...
I could certainly see AI interesting the rate of scientific breakthroughs and so leading to a technological golden age (room temperature semi conductors, cures for many diseases, quantum computing)
Or it could just lead to mass unemployment and an even bigger wealth gap
Or anything in between, I guess we'll see
> average quality of life is up massively
In what ways massively? Do you factor in negative externalities like ecosystem damage? Do you differentiate what was improved because of industralization and what would be improved regardless?
Because there's nothing left after that...
Woodchipper scene from Fargo, that describes what is happening to labor in the economy.