Who knows, maybe there's a third proof. Maybe everyone and their grandmother proved the GRH and we peons just haven't gotten the memo. Maybe when we make first contact with aliens, their self-interpreting code will just rattle off GRH.
After GRH, I guess all the millennium problems are fair game now. It's only a question of who's willing to burn enough compute on a fundamental math question that will most likely not meaningfully alter your quarterly revenue report.
I think GRH will be a distinct inflection point. There's a genuine sense in which math is effectively solved. We now know that it's almost certainly possible to push as far as we want, within reason, and the limiting factor is just compute.
Interesting idea, regarding math being solved. Mathematics is notoriously practical as a tool for imparting tools to science and engineering. Often in surprising ways! With this in mind, do you think, now that mathematics is solved, we will be stunted in learning new tools for physics, chemistry etc. Perhaps those are solved also? Or perhaps we will never be able to make further progress on them, now that we have reached mathematics' edge. Precipice? Phlegethon, with flames extending through heaven and hearth? Or is it a closed geometry, and past the Reimann hypothesis, we found ourselves back at Euclid?
I think math just basically becomes infrastructure for everything else you mentioned: physics, chemistry, biology, engineering, etc. We direct compute on math research based on what seems useful for those disciplines. Out of curiosity, individual researchers may still pursue directions in math for their own elegance or beauty, but the large clusters will make most real progress and will be allocated based on how math-as-infrastructure can accelerate progress in other domains.
I don't think those other domains are solved yet, because they involve hard experimental loops that we can't automate in Lean and AI agents. It just so happens that pure math can be almost entirely captured in a purely digital and verifiable form. Another way of saying this is that math basically is formal / verifiably correct reasoning, and the combination of scalable AI reasoning and software like Lean effectively solves it as a result. Of course, math is infinite: you can run compute forever on it and keep getting new and true statements. So while I'm saying it's solved, I'm not saying there are no discoveries left to make. I believe it's solved in the sense that we now have a reliable, repeatable technique for pushing in any direction, as far as we want, as measured by how much money we're willing to dedicate to it.
It's a bit of wordplay to call an entire field "solved", but if we get room temperature superconductors in exchange for everyone getting unemployed, maybe the Terminators won't crush us?
Now that we have math solved and IPO cashed out etc., can we start instead allocating the capital into advancing robotics and human health or something like that that's nice and exists in the real world and not only in the tubes of the world wide web?
If stuff like cure for cancer, alzheimer...etc. is too hard.
There's a long list of other "mundane" stuff that for a long time we've been promised AI/robots wound take on, so that humans could spend more time on arts and other more pleasurable/interesting things.
Let me know when AI proposes new axioms independent of our current theories of arithmetic that are true in the standard model. Until then, I wouldn’t call math “solved”.
Apartments should be free, as long as you’re willing to move within 50km of your place of work, or anywhere if unemployed.
If you want a big house, boo hoo pay for it, but somewhere along the line we were convinced the government owns all the land and we have to pay for it. In reality, nobody owns the Earth, it belongs to every human, so at a basic level you should not have to pay for a plot to live. That would be paying for your human rights.
Children should be surrendered to the government as wards while we’re at it.
Makes no sense to live 50km away from your workplace and relegate the children 10 to 12 hours per day to school (saving just the worst parts: bed routine to be “shared”)
Gone for me.
The repo exists but is empty.
Dead link for me. If it exists, it might be hidden and/or private.
"What do you think they've solved? My guess is the Riemann Hypothesis."
Spoke too soon seems Anthropic and Levent Alpöge just claimed it first!"
Who knows, maybe there's a third proof. Maybe everyone and their grandmother proved the GRH and we peons just haven't gotten the memo. Maybe when we make first contact with aliens, their self-interpreting code will just rattle off GRH.
After GRH, I guess all the millennium problems are fair game now. It's only a question of who's willing to burn enough compute on a fundamental math question that will most likely not meaningfully alter your quarterly revenue report.
I think GRH will be a distinct inflection point. There's a genuine sense in which math is effectively solved. We now know that it's almost certainly possible to push as far as we want, within reason, and the limiting factor is just compute.
Interesting idea, regarding math being solved. Mathematics is notoriously practical as a tool for imparting tools to science and engineering. Often in surprising ways! With this in mind, do you think, now that mathematics is solved, we will be stunted in learning new tools for physics, chemistry etc. Perhaps those are solved also? Or perhaps we will never be able to make further progress on them, now that we have reached mathematics' edge. Precipice? Phlegethon, with flames extending through heaven and hearth? Or is it a closed geometry, and past the Reimann hypothesis, we found ourselves back at Euclid?
I think math just basically becomes infrastructure for everything else you mentioned: physics, chemistry, biology, engineering, etc. We direct compute on math research based on what seems useful for those disciplines. Out of curiosity, individual researchers may still pursue directions in math for their own elegance or beauty, but the large clusters will make most real progress and will be allocated based on how math-as-infrastructure can accelerate progress in other domains.
I don't think those other domains are solved yet, because they involve hard experimental loops that we can't automate in Lean and AI agents. It just so happens that pure math can be almost entirely captured in a purely digital and verifiable form. Another way of saying this is that math basically is formal / verifiably correct reasoning, and the combination of scalable AI reasoning and software like Lean effectively solves it as a result. Of course, math is infinite: you can run compute forever on it and keep getting new and true statements. So while I'm saying it's solved, I'm not saying there are no discoveries left to make. I believe it's solved in the sense that we now have a reliable, repeatable technique for pushing in any direction, as far as we want, as measured by how much money we're willing to dedicate to it.
It's a bit of wordplay to call an entire field "solved", but if we get room temperature superconductors in exchange for everyone getting unemployed, maybe the Terminators won't crush us?
Now that we have math solved and IPO cashed out etc., can we start instead allocating the capital into advancing robotics and human health or something like that that's nice and exists in the real world and not only in the tubes of the world wide web?
Careful what you wish for.
Robots are coming, and then we're really in trouble.
Chilling while robots do all the work sounds good to me.
Whose robots? If they aren't yours somehow, why would you benefit?
We have observed that humans cease to function after being chilled, but if that is your preference it will make things easier.
If stuff like cure for cancer, alzheimer...etc. is too hard.
There's a long list of other "mundane" stuff that for a long time we've been promised AI/robots wound take on, so that humans could spend more time on arts and other more pleasurable/interesting things.
Like King Midas, you should be careful what you wish for
I second the call for Human Health/Bionics singularity :)
> Now that we have math solved
Let me know when AI proposes new axioms independent of our current theories of arithmetic that are true in the standard model. Until then, I wouldn’t call math “solved”.
Can we just cancel all debt, mortgages, rent, taxes, and fines? Let AI take care of it. I’m only half joking.
Apartments should be free, as long as you’re willing to move within 50km of your place of work, or anywhere if unemployed.
If you want a big house, boo hoo pay for it, but somewhere along the line we were convinced the government owns all the land and we have to pay for it. In reality, nobody owns the Earth, it belongs to every human, so at a basic level you should not have to pay for a plot to live. That would be paying for your human rights.
That's a good idea, but what if one's unemployed?
Then you go where the government can find you something available. It’s kind of a tough luck but better than nothing situation.
Yeah, I suppose you can take that route but it also depends on the health and age of the person in question.
Thanks for the feedback :)
Children should be surrendered to the government as wards while we’re at it. Makes no sense to live 50km away from your workplace and relegate the children 10 to 12 hours per day to school (saving just the worst parts: bed routine to be “shared”)
Unfortunately the men with guns don't subscribe to your beautiful world view.
Why would we do that? We should invest all on exploiting human attention /s.
aaaand it's gone
[dead]