I had a professor (emeritus) in grad school that was the fantasy of any human geneticist. He was one of the first scientists in Japan after the atomic bombs and studied their effects - elevated soft-tissue cancers at the beginning and later elevated hard-tissue cancers.
Later he did genetics on the Yanomami Indians in Brazil. It was interesting but what I found that was more interesting was when a chief of the Indians made a tour of the USA. He was on npr taking call ins and people were calling in saying how amazing it was that his people were able to live in nature, live like they've lived for thousands of years, and with every caller he answered, no, they just want to educate their children and give them opportunities that they don't have.
This is what happens to older forms of civilization when newer competitors arise in their vicinity. We do expend some effort to preserve a continuum of civilization from primitive tribes to 21st century democracies and everything inbetween, but there's a limit to how much the long tail can be stretched before older forms get their livable space compressed below viability as a side effect of the higher civilizations' activity. And I reject the solution of freezing change/progress altogether - that feels just as aesthetically displeasing as destroying older forms of civilization.
One possible long term solution is for newer forms to spread out into space at the speed of light so that the side effects of their activity never propagate to the older forms.
This reminds me of the story of Ishi, the indigenous Californian who, after years of living alone as the last of his kind, was forced by starvation and forest fire and old age to leave his mountain home and spend the rest of his days among the hated settlers. These people must have been absolutely desperate.
"The Araribóia, which has no buffer to protect its forests, has in recent years been besieged by illegal loggers, poachers and land grabbers. More than 70 percent of the territory was consumed by fire in 2024, according to government reporting ... one of the Indigenous groups that share the territory with the Awá, have formed the “forest guardians,” an armed group that patrols the vast territory. Several of them have been killed in what they’ve described as “battle.”"
There is a good concept for that kind of lawless frontier, it's called Organized Abandonment or Zones of Exception
One of the useful ideas I've gotten from the Fredy Perlman was the sense that perty much every culture that has come into contact with (what folks around me think of as) "the west" has either had to form it's own rigid and psychopathic order, be appropriated into the order by force, or be destroyed.
Not a reference I expected to see on HN of all places, but very welcome! Against His-tory, Against Leviathan (which I guess you're referring to) hugely shaped my understanding of history, Letters of Insurgents my understanding of anarchism and 20th-century Left movements, and his essay "The Reproduction of Daily Life" is one of the most accessible explainers of Marxist economic theory I've ever read. Great writer, criminally underrated.
https://archive.is/6gQYV
I had a professor (emeritus) in grad school that was the fantasy of any human geneticist. He was one of the first scientists in Japan after the atomic bombs and studied their effects - elevated soft-tissue cancers at the beginning and later elevated hard-tissue cancers.
Later he did genetics on the Yanomami Indians in Brazil. It was interesting but what I found that was more interesting was when a chief of the Indians made a tour of the USA. He was on npr taking call ins and people were calling in saying how amazing it was that his people were able to live in nature, live like they've lived for thousands of years, and with every caller he answered, no, they just want to educate their children and give them opportunities that they don't have.
This is what happens to older forms of civilization when newer competitors arise in their vicinity. We do expend some effort to preserve a continuum of civilization from primitive tribes to 21st century democracies and everything inbetween, but there's a limit to how much the long tail can be stretched before older forms get their livable space compressed below viability as a side effect of the higher civilizations' activity. And I reject the solution of freezing change/progress altogether - that feels just as aesthetically displeasing as destroying older forms of civilization.
One possible long term solution is for newer forms to spread out into space at the speed of light so that the side effects of their activity never propagate to the older forms.
This reminds me of the story of Ishi, the indigenous Californian who, after years of living alone as the last of his kind, was forced by starvation and forest fire and old age to leave his mountain home and spend the rest of his days among the hated settlers. These people must have been absolutely desperate.
Wow, I wonder what's wrong with their environment to have forced this decision?
"The Araribóia, which has no buffer to protect its forests, has in recent years been besieged by illegal loggers, poachers and land grabbers. More than 70 percent of the territory was consumed by fire in 2024, according to government reporting ... one of the Indigenous groups that share the territory with the Awá, have formed the “forest guardians,” an armed group that patrols the vast territory. Several of them have been killed in what they’ve described as “battle.”"
There is a good concept for that kind of lawless frontier, it's called Organized Abandonment or Zones of Exception
It's not a good sign at all.
Our so-called beautiful civilization has destroyed most of their world.
One of the useful ideas I've gotten from the Fredy Perlman was the sense that perty much every culture that has come into contact with (what folks around me think of as) "the west" has either had to form it's own rigid and psychopathic order, be appropriated into the order by force, or be destroyed.
Not a reference I expected to see on HN of all places, but very welcome! Against His-tory, Against Leviathan (which I guess you're referring to) hugely shaped my understanding of history, Letters of Insurgents my understanding of anarchism and 20th-century Left movements, and his essay "The Reproduction of Daily Life" is one of the most accessible explainers of Marxist economic theory I've ever read. Great writer, criminally underrated.
Yes, that's about right. Unfortunately.
[flagged]
I'm actually more concerned about the welfare of the nonhuman life.
There are 198 places (tribes?) per https://www.uncontactedpeoples.org/
Few more comments 3 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538555
my brain parsed that originally as:
> Uncontacted Indigenous people emerge from Amazon warehouse to ask for food
It is an incredibly tragic story, but you did make me laugh, so thank you.
Offering as barter, traditional tea that they'd made and stored in discarded plastic water bottles.
Not to make light of this tragic situation… that would make a great Onion headline.
How about: engineers emerge from data warehouse to ask for food? Driven out. An exodus is upon us.