When I see the words "AI safety", the first two words that come to mind are "regulatory capture." It is in frontier companies' interests to do so ASAP. Qui bono?
Yet, despite asking on many of the threads where your position is stated, I have yet to find even one other example to compare against of an industry which has claimed, top to bottom, with people leaving specifically to have more freedom to speak, that the product of the industry is a general threat to humanity.
Has any coal miner or coal power station owner emphasised climate risks, demanded regulation to phase out coal? Surely someone can find one example of this? Never makes headlines, though. Strikes, to mine more coal at higher pay and/or better working conditions, those make headlines.
Do nuclear reactor operators (company or individual) emphasise the dual-use of their systems, that the neutrons they emit can be used to manufacture plutonium and thus they pose a risk of rapid proliferation should any nation with nuclear reactors but no nuclear weapons should decide it wants the weapons? Again, surely there must be some, but they don't make the headlines.
Did the companies making PFAS talk about the risks? The headlines have been how they downplayed them. Asbestos? Social media?
Closest I have ever found was the never-built Sundial weapon, but even that wasn't regulatory caputure, it was M.A.D.
Regulatory capture is a thing. I wouldn't put it past any billionaire to try it. Doesn't seem to explain this, though.
When I see the words "AI safety", the first two words that come to mind are "regulatory capture." It is in frontier companies' interests to do so ASAP. Qui bono?
Regulatory capture is a thing.
Yet, despite asking on many of the threads where your position is stated, I have yet to find even one other example to compare against of an industry which has claimed, top to bottom, with people leaving specifically to have more freedom to speak, that the product of the industry is a general threat to humanity.
Has any coal miner or coal power station owner emphasised climate risks, demanded regulation to phase out coal? Surely someone can find one example of this? Never makes headlines, though. Strikes, to mine more coal at higher pay and/or better working conditions, those make headlines.
Do nuclear reactor operators (company or individual) emphasise the dual-use of their systems, that the neutrons they emit can be used to manufacture plutonium and thus they pose a risk of rapid proliferation should any nation with nuclear reactors but no nuclear weapons should decide it wants the weapons? Again, surely there must be some, but they don't make the headlines.
Did the companies making PFAS talk about the risks? The headlines have been how they downplayed them. Asbestos? Social media?
Closest I have ever found was the never-built Sundial weapon, but even that wasn't regulatory caputure, it was M.A.D.
Regulatory capture is a thing. I wouldn't put it past any billionaire to try it. Doesn't seem to explain this, though.
I think it benefits all of us, sometimes we don’t worry about something until we’re the ones that are directly affected.