Re the myth-busting of serpentine wall strength, I wonder if there's a considerable oversight?
The wall impact test showing the serpentine (thinner) wall to be weaker to a perpendicular strike than a linear (thicker) wall sounds expected if connection between bricks is modeled only as friction between bricks resting upon their neighbors; the ball strike punches through the thinner wall more readily than the thinker.
But if the bricks are glued together with mortar, the dynamic may change a lot.
Assume that the friction of mortar increases the tensile strength of the wall by orders of magnitude beyond the friction between stacked bricks:
There's a crossover point of friction where the integrity of the wall is a function of its entire mesh; glued bricks may distribute enough force across the length of the wall that whether the wall stands is a function of its total mass resting upon the wall's base width relative to the strike (assume a perpendicular strike). If friction holds the bricks together enough to transfer force from the strike across the length of the wall, A serpentine wall presents a base as wide as the amplitude of its wave, making it more stable against being tipped over than a straight wall.
Also the curve of the wave may direct more force of a strike longitudinally affecting the transfer of forces between bricks: the serpentine form presents arches relative to a lateral strike; bricks transfer force across the mess via compression rather than tension, a great strength advantage for stone building.
I suspect that if the connection between bricks is modeled in further detail, a serpentine arrangement can be found to be stronger than a straight wall as well as more materials efficient.
Not simulating mortar is a significant oversight in this experiment.
I've seen a few myself.
A nice collection here: https://www.geograph.org.uk/gallery/crinkle_crankle_or_serpe...
Re the myth-busting of serpentine wall strength, I wonder if there's a considerable oversight?
The wall impact test showing the serpentine (thinner) wall to be weaker to a perpendicular strike than a linear (thicker) wall sounds expected if connection between bricks is modeled only as friction between bricks resting upon their neighbors; the ball strike punches through the thinner wall more readily than the thinker.
But if the bricks are glued together with mortar, the dynamic may change a lot.
Assume that the friction of mortar increases the tensile strength of the wall by orders of magnitude beyond the friction between stacked bricks:
There's a crossover point of friction where the integrity of the wall is a function of its entire mesh; glued bricks may distribute enough force across the length of the wall that whether the wall stands is a function of its total mass resting upon the wall's base width relative to the strike (assume a perpendicular strike). If friction holds the bricks together enough to transfer force from the strike across the length of the wall, A serpentine wall presents a base as wide as the amplitude of its wave, making it more stable against being tipped over than a straight wall.
Also the curve of the wave may direct more force of a strike longitudinally affecting the transfer of forces between bricks: the serpentine form presents arches relative to a lateral strike; bricks transfer force across the mess via compression rather than tension, a great strength advantage for stone building.
I suspect that if the connection between bricks is modeled in further detail, a serpentine arrangement can be found to be stronger than a straight wall as well as more materials efficient.
Not simulating mortar is a significant oversight in this experiment.